Study of the multi-waveband flux and the black hole mass of RBLs and XBLs

Bao Yu-Ying; Chen Luo-En; Zhang Xiong; Peng Zhao-Yang; Li Huai-Zhen

doi:10.7498/aps.59.3618

Abstract

The spectral variation, the correlation of multi-waveband flux and the property of polarization of BL Lac objects give us important information for studying their intrinsic correlation of radiation components. The present paper analyzes the properties of RBLs and XBLs. It is indicated by statistics that the redshift of RBLs are greater than that of XBLs and the black hole mass of RBLs are smaller than that of XBLs. The paper also studies the possible correlations between the redshift and the flux densities for different wavebands in low state, and the possible correlations of flux densities for different wavebands (radio, near-infrared, optical and X-ray) in low state. The results support that the systematic difference between RBLs and XBLs is not caused by the choice effect only.

Keywords:

BL Lac objects /
multi-waveband flux

Authors and contacts

(1)玉溪师范学院物理系，玉溪 653100; (2)云南师范大学物理与电子信息学院，昆明 650092

References

[1]	［1］Blandford R D, Rees M J 1978 Phys. 17 265
[2]	［2］Stickel M, Padovani P, Urry C M, Fried J W, Kuehr H 1991 ApJ. 374 431
[3]	［3］ Stocke J T, Morris S L, Gioia I M, Maccacaro T, Schild R, Wolter A, Fleming T A, Henry J P 1991 ApJS 76 813
[4]	［4］Stocke J T, Liebert J, Schmidt G, Gioia I M, Maccacaro T, Schild R E, Maccagni D, Arp H C 1985 ApJ 298 619
[5]	［5］Heidt J, Wagner S J 1998 A&A 329 853
[6]	［6］Bai J M, Xie G Z, Li K H, Zhang X, Liu W W 1998 A&AS 132 83
[7]	［7］Morris S L, Stocke J T, Gioia I M, Schild R E, Wolter A, Maccacaro T, Della C R 1991 ApJ 380 49
[8]	［8］Xie G Z, Zhang X, Bai J M, Xie Z H 1998 ApJ 508 180
[9]	［9］ Kollgaard R I, Gabuzda D C, Feigelson E D1996 ApJ 460 174
[10]	］ Laurent-Muehleisen S A, Kollgaard R I, Moellenbrock G A, Feigelson E D 1993 AJ 106 875
[11]	］ Kollgaard R I, Palma C, Laurent-Muehleisen S A, Feigelson E D 1996 ApJ 465 115
[12]	］Perlman E S, Stocke J T, Wang Q D, Morris S L 1996 ApJ 456 451
[13]	］Ghisellini G, Maraschi L, Treves A, Tanzi E G 1986 ApJ 310 317
[14]	］Maraschi L, Ghisellini G, Tanzi E G, Treves A 1986 ApJ 310 325
[15]	］ Kaspi S, Smith P S, Netzer H, Maoz D, Jannuzi B T, Giveon U 2000 ApJ 533 631
[16]	］ Ferrarese L, Richard W, Peterson B M, Merritt D 2001 ApJ 555 79
[17]	］Gebhardt K, Bender R, Bower G, Dressler Alan, Faber S M, Filippenko A V, Green R, Grillmair C, Ho L C, Kormendy J 2000 ApJ 539 13
[18]	］ Xie G Z, Liu B F, Liu F K, Lu R W, Li K H, Zhu Y Y 1991A&A 249 65
[19]	］ Wu X B, Liu F K, Zhang T Z 2002 A&A 389 742
[20]	］Weiler K W, Johnston K J 1980 MNRAS 190 269
[21]	［21 ］Fossati G, Maraschi L, Celotti A, Comastri A, Ghisellini G 1998 MNRAS 299 433
[22]	］ Data from the University of Michigan Radio Astronomy Observatory
[23]	［23 ］Ghisellini G, Haardt F, Fabian A C 1993 MNRAS 263 9
[24]	］Doxsey R, Bradt H, McClintock J, Petro L, Remillard R, Schwartz D, Wood K, Ricker G 1983 ApJ 264 43
[25]	］Biermann P, Duerbeck H, Eckart A, Fricke K, Johnston K J, Kuhr H, Liebert J, Pauliny Toth I I K, Schleicher H, Stockman H 1981 ApJ 247 53
[26]	］Cruz-Gonzalez I, Huchra J P 1984 AJ 89 441
[27]	］Worrall D M, Puschell J J, Bruhweiler F C, Sitko M L, Stein W A, Aller M F, Aller H D, Hodge P E, Rudy R J, Miller H R 1984 ApJ 284 512
[28]	］Worrall D M, Rodriguez-Espinosa J M, Wisniewski W Z, Miller H R, Bruhweiler F C, Aller M F, Aller H D 1986 ApJ 303 589
[29]	］Angel J R P, Stockman H S 1980 ARA&A 18 321
[30]	］Ledden J E, Odell S L 1985 ApJ 298 630
[31]	］Bregman J N, Glassgold A E, Huggins P J, Pollock J T, Pica A J, Smith A G, Webb J R, Ku W H M, Rudy R J, Levan P D 1982 ApJ 253 19
[32]	］Miley G, Neugebauer G, Soifer B T, Clegg P E, Harris S, Rowan-Robinson M, Young E 1984 ApJ 278 79
[33]	］Comastri A, Fossati G, Ghisellini G, Molendi S 1997 ApJ 480 534
[34]	］ Mead A R G, Ballard K R, Brand P W J L, Hough J H, Brindle C, Bailey J A 1990 A&AS 83 183
[35]	］Takalo L O, Kidger M R, de Diego J A, Sillanpaa A, Nilsson K 1992 AJ 104 40
[36]	］Falomo R, Treves A, Chiappetti L, Maraschi L, Pian E, Tanzi E G 1993 ApJ 402 532
[37]	］Fan J H, Lin R G 1999 ApJS 121 131
[38]	］Massaro E, Nesci R, Perola G C, Lorenzetti D, Spinoglio L 1995A&A 299 339
[39]	］Fan J H, Feng X H, Su C Y 1999 PyunO 2 1
[40]	］Litchfield S J, Robson E I, Stevens J A 1994 MNRAS 270 341
[41]	］Kidger M R,de Diego J A 1992 A&AS 93 1
[42]	］Hec kman T M, Lebofsky M J, Rieke G H, van Breugel W 1983 ApJ 272 400
[43]	］Bersanelli M, Bouchet P, Falomo R, Tanzi E G 1992 AJ 104 28
[44]	］Bregman J N, Glassgold A E, Huggins P J, Neugebauer G, Soifer B T, Matthews K, Elias J H, Webb J R, Pollock J T, Leacock R J 1990 ApJ 352 574
[45]	］Brown L M J, Robson E I, Gear W K, Hughes D H, Griffin M J, Geldzahler B J, Schwartz P R, Smith M G, Smith A G, Shepherd D W 1989 ApJ 340 129
[46]	］Stickel M, Fried J W, Kuehr H 1988 A&A 191 16
[47]	］Falomo R, Scarpa R, Bersanelli M 1994 ApJS 93 125
[48]	］Madau P, Ghisellini G, Persic M 1987 MNRAS 224 257
[49]	］Fan J H, Lin R G 2000 ApJ 537 101
[50]	］Wills B J, Wills D, Evans N J II, Natta A, Thompson K L, Breger M, Sitko M L 1992 ApJ 400 96
[51]	］ Mufson S L, Hutter D J, Hackney K R H, Hackney R L, Kondo Y, Mushotzky R F, Urry C M, Wisniewski W Z, Aller M F, Aller H D 1982 NASCP 2238 185
[52]	］ Wills B J, Pollock J T, Aller H D, Aller M F, Balonek T J, Barvainis R E, Binzel R P, Chaffee F H, Dent W A, Douglas J N 1983 ApJ 274 62
[53]	］Ledden J E, Odell S L, Stein W A, Wisniewski W Z 1981 ApJ 243 47
[54]	］Webb J R, Smith A G, Leacock R J, Fitzgibbons G L, Gombola P P, Shepherd D W 1988 AJ 95 374
[55]	］Odell S L, Puschell J J, Stein W A, Owen F, Porcas R W, Mufson S, Moffett T J, Ulrich M H 1978 ApJ 224 22
[56]	］Westerlund B E, Wlerick G, Garnier R 1982 A&A 105 284
[57]	］Oke J B, Goodrich R W 1981 ApJ 243 445
[58]	］Wall J V, Peacock J A 1985 MNRAS 216 173
[59]	］Angione R J 1971 AJ 76 412
[60]	］Sambruna R M, Maraschi L, Urry C M 1996 ApJ 463 444
[61]	］Lamer G, Brunner H, Staubert R 1996 A&A 311 384
[62]	］Madejski G M, Schwartz D A 1983 ApJ 275 467
[63]	］Urry C M, Sambruna R M, Worrall D M, Kollgaard R I, Feigelson E D, Perlman E S, Stocke J T 1996 ApJ 463 424
[64]	］Treves A, Belloni T, Falomo R, Fink H, Maraschi L, Sambruna R M, Tagliaferri G, Zimmermann H U 1993 ApJ 406 447
[65]	］Bloom S D, Marscher A P, Moore E M, Gear W, Tersranta H, Valtaoja E, Aller H D, Aller M F 1999 ApJS 122 1
[66]	］Fichtel C E 1994 ApJS 90 917
[67]	］Sambruna R M 1997 ApJ 487 536
[68]	］Sambruna R M, Barr P, Giommi P, Maraschi L, Tagliaferri G, Treves A 1994 ApJ 434 468
[69]	］Giommi P, Ansari S G, Micol A 1995 A&AS 109 267
[70]	］Makino F 1989 ESASP 296 803

Cited By

[1]	［1］Blandford R D, Rees M J 1978 Phys. 17 265
[2]	［2］Stickel M, Padovani P, Urry C M, Fried J W, Kuehr H 1991 ApJ. 374 431
[3]	［3］ Stocke J T, Morris S L, Gioia I M, Maccacaro T, Schild R, Wolter A, Fleming T A, Henry J P 1991 ApJS 76 813
[4]	［4］Stocke J T, Liebert J, Schmidt G, Gioia I M, Maccacaro T, Schild R E, Maccagni D, Arp H C 1985 ApJ 298 619
[5]	［5］Heidt J, Wagner S J 1998 A&A 329 853
[6]	［6］Bai J M, Xie G Z, Li K H, Zhang X, Liu W W 1998 A&AS 132 83
[7]	［7］Morris S L, Stocke J T, Gioia I M, Schild R E, Wolter A, Maccacaro T, Della C R 1991 ApJ 380 49
[8]	［8］Xie G Z, Zhang X, Bai J M, Xie Z H 1998 ApJ 508 180
[9]	［9］ Kollgaard R I, Gabuzda D C, Feigelson E D1996 ApJ 460 174
[10]	］ Laurent-Muehleisen S A, Kollgaard R I, Moellenbrock G A, Feigelson E D 1993 AJ 106 875
[11]	］ Kollgaard R I, Palma C, Laurent-Muehleisen S A, Feigelson E D 1996 ApJ 465 115
[12]	］Perlman E S, Stocke J T, Wang Q D, Morris S L 1996 ApJ 456 451
[13]	］Ghisellini G, Maraschi L, Treves A, Tanzi E G 1986 ApJ 310 317
[14]	］Maraschi L, Ghisellini G, Tanzi E G, Treves A 1986 ApJ 310 325
[15]	］ Kaspi S, Smith P S, Netzer H, Maoz D, Jannuzi B T, Giveon U 2000 ApJ 533 631
[16]	］ Ferrarese L, Richard W, Peterson B M, Merritt D 2001 ApJ 555 79
[17]	］Gebhardt K, Bender R, Bower G, Dressler Alan, Faber S M, Filippenko A V, Green R, Grillmair C, Ho L C, Kormendy J 2000 ApJ 539 13
[18]	］ Xie G Z, Liu B F, Liu F K, Lu R W, Li K H, Zhu Y Y 1991A&A 249 65
[19]	］ Wu X B, Liu F K, Zhang T Z 2002 A&A 389 742
[20]	］Weiler K W, Johnston K J 1980 MNRAS 190 269
[21]	［21 ］Fossati G, Maraschi L, Celotti A, Comastri A, Ghisellini G 1998 MNRAS 299 433
[22]	］ Data from the University of Michigan Radio Astronomy Observatory
[23]	［23 ］Ghisellini G, Haardt F, Fabian A C 1993 MNRAS 263 9
[24]	］Doxsey R, Bradt H, McClintock J, Petro L, Remillard R, Schwartz D, Wood K, Ricker G 1983 ApJ 264 43
[25]	］Biermann P, Duerbeck H, Eckart A, Fricke K, Johnston K J, Kuhr H, Liebert J, Pauliny Toth I I K, Schleicher H, Stockman H 1981 ApJ 247 53
[26]	］Cruz-Gonzalez I, Huchra J P 1984 AJ 89 441
[27]	］Worrall D M, Puschell J J, Bruhweiler F C, Sitko M L, Stein W A, Aller M F, Aller H D, Hodge P E, Rudy R J, Miller H R 1984 ApJ 284 512
[28]	］Worrall D M, Rodriguez-Espinosa J M, Wisniewski W Z, Miller H R, Bruhweiler F C, Aller M F, Aller H D 1986 ApJ 303 589
[29]	］Angel J R P, Stockman H S 1980 ARA&A 18 321
[30]	］Ledden J E, Odell S L 1985 ApJ 298 630
[31]	］Bregman J N, Glassgold A E, Huggins P J, Pollock J T, Pica A J, Smith A G, Webb J R, Ku W H M, Rudy R J, Levan P D 1982 ApJ 253 19
[32]	］Miley G, Neugebauer G, Soifer B T, Clegg P E, Harris S, Rowan-Robinson M, Young E 1984 ApJ 278 79
[33]	］Comastri A, Fossati G, Ghisellini G, Molendi S 1997 ApJ 480 534
[34]	］ Mead A R G, Ballard K R, Brand P W J L, Hough J H, Brindle C, Bailey J A 1990 A&AS 83 183
[35]	］Takalo L O, Kidger M R, de Diego J A, Sillanpaa A, Nilsson K 1992 AJ 104 40
[36]	］Falomo R, Treves A, Chiappetti L, Maraschi L, Pian E, Tanzi E G 1993 ApJ 402 532
[37]	］Fan J H, Lin R G 1999 ApJS 121 131
[38]	］Massaro E, Nesci R, Perola G C, Lorenzetti D, Spinoglio L 1995A&A 299 339
[39]	］Fan J H, Feng X H, Su C Y 1999 PyunO 2 1
[40]	］Litchfield S J, Robson E I, Stevens J A 1994 MNRAS 270 341
[41]	］Kidger M R,de Diego J A 1992 A&AS 93 1
[42]	］Hec kman T M, Lebofsky M J, Rieke G H, van Breugel W 1983 ApJ 272 400
[43]	］Bersanelli M, Bouchet P, Falomo R, Tanzi E G 1992 AJ 104 28
[44]	］Bregman J N, Glassgold A E, Huggins P J, Neugebauer G, Soifer B T, Matthews K, Elias J H, Webb J R, Pollock J T, Leacock R J 1990 ApJ 352 574
[45]	］Brown L M J, Robson E I, Gear W K, Hughes D H, Griffin M J, Geldzahler B J, Schwartz P R, Smith M G, Smith A G, Shepherd D W 1989 ApJ 340 129
[46]	］Stickel M, Fried J W, Kuehr H 1988 A&A 191 16
[47]	］Falomo R, Scarpa R, Bersanelli M 1994 ApJS 93 125
[48]	］Madau P, Ghisellini G, Persic M 1987 MNRAS 224 257
[49]	］Fan J H, Lin R G 2000 ApJ 537 101
[50]	］Wills B J, Wills D, Evans N J II, Natta A, Thompson K L, Breger M, Sitko M L 1992 ApJ 400 96
[51]	］ Mufson S L, Hutter D J, Hackney K R H, Hackney R L, Kondo Y, Mushotzky R F, Urry C M, Wisniewski W Z, Aller M F, Aller H D 1982 NASCP 2238 185
[52]	］ Wills B J, Pollock J T, Aller H D, Aller M F, Balonek T J, Barvainis R E, Binzel R P, Chaffee F H, Dent W A, Douglas J N 1983 ApJ 274 62
[53]	］Ledden J E, Odell S L, Stein W A, Wisniewski W Z 1981 ApJ 243 47
[54]	］Webb J R, Smith A G, Leacock R J, Fitzgibbons G L, Gombola P P, Shepherd D W 1988 AJ 95 374
[55]	］Odell S L, Puschell J J, Stein W A, Owen F, Porcas R W, Mufson S, Moffett T J, Ulrich M H 1978 ApJ 224 22
[56]	］Westerlund B E, Wlerick G, Garnier R 1982 A&A 105 284
[57]	］Oke J B, Goodrich R W 1981 ApJ 243 445
[58]	］Wall J V, Peacock J A 1985 MNRAS 216 173
[59]	］Angione R J 1971 AJ 76 412
[60]	］Sambruna R M, Maraschi L, Urry C M 1996 ApJ 463 444
[61]	］Lamer G, Brunner H, Staubert R 1996 A&A 311 384
[62]	］Madejski G M, Schwartz D A 1983 ApJ 275 467
[63]	］Urry C M, Sambruna R M, Worrall D M, Kollgaard R I, Feigelson E D, Perlman E S, Stocke J T 1996 ApJ 463 424
[64]	］Treves A, Belloni T, Falomo R, Fink H, Maraschi L, Sambruna R M, Tagliaferri G, Zimmermann H U 1993 ApJ 406 447
[65]	］Bloom S D, Marscher A P, Moore E M, Gear W, Tersranta H, Valtaoja E, Aller H D, Aller M F 1999 ApJS 122 1
[66]	］Fichtel C E 1994 ApJS 90 917
[67]	］Sambruna R M 1997 ApJ 487 536
[68]	］Sambruna R M, Barr P, Giommi P, Maraschi L, Tagliaferri G, Treves A 1994 ApJ 434 468
[69]	］Giommi P, Ansari S G, Micol A 1995 A&AS 109 267
[70]	］Makino F 1989 ESASP 296 803

[1]	Song Jian, Ren Feng, Hu Hai-Bao, Chen Xiao-Peng. Effect of synthetic jet on circular cylinder radiated noise in laminar flow state. Acta Physica Sinica, 2023, 72(4): 044702. doi: 10.7498/aps.72.20221879
[2]	Yang Meng-Qi, Wu Fu-Yuan, Chen Zhi-Bo, Zhang Yi-Xiang, Chen Yi, Zhang Jin-Chuan, Chen Zhi-Zhen, Fang Zhi-Fan, Rafael Ramis, Zhang Jie. Two-dimensional radiation hydrodynamic simulations of high-speed head-on collisions between high-density plasma jets. Acta Physica Sinica, 2022, 71(22): 225202. doi: 10.7498/aps.71.20220948
[3]	Qing Wen-Tao, Zhi Qi-Jun, Yang You-Chang. Calculations of electron capture rates of ⁶⁶Fe in astrophysical enviroment. Acta Physica Sinica, 2022, 71(19): 192101. doi: 10.7498/aps.71.20220929
[4]	Zhang Huan, Zhang Hao-Jing, Lu Lin, Ma Kai-Xuan. Multiwavelength corss-correlation and radio Doppler factor estimation of CGRaBS J2345-1555. Acta Physica Sinica, 2021, 70(21): 219501. doi: 10.7498/aps.70.20210745
[5]	Cao Miao-Miao, Liu Wen-Xin, Wang Yong, Zhu Jue-Yuan, Li Ke. High frequency characteristics of dielectric-loaded grating for terahertz Smith-Purcell radiation. Acta Physica Sinica, 2016, 65(1): 014101. doi: 10.7498/aps.65.014101
[6]	Hu Shuai, Gao Tai-Chang, Li Hao, Liu Lei, Cheng Tian-Ji, Zhang Ting. Influence of atmospheric refraction on radiative transfer at visible light band. Acta Physica Sinica, 2015, 64(18): 184203. doi: 10.7498/aps.64.184203
[7]	Du Yan-Lei, Ma Wen-Tao, Yang Xiao-Feng, Liu Gui-Hong, Yu Yang, Li Zi-Wei. A rapid atmospheric correction model for L-band microwave radiometer under the cloudless condition. Acta Physica Sinica, 2015, 64(7): 079501. doi: 10.7498/aps.64.079501
[8]	Ling Wei-Jun, Zhang Shao-Gang, Li Ke, Zhang Ming-Xia, Wang Yi-Shan, Zhao Wei, Wang Zhao-Hua, Wei Zhi-Yi. Multi-wavelength ultraviolet terawatt-order CPA system. Acta Physica Sinica, 2011, 60(11): 114215. doi: 10.7498/aps.60.114215
[9]	Tang Jie, Wu Xue-Bing. Classification of Blazar objects based on Logistic regression model. Acta Physica Sinica, 2011, 60(11): 119801. doi: 10.7498/aps.60.119801
[10]	Tang Jie, Zhang Xiong. Optical variability periodicity analysis of BL Lac object S5 0716+714 based on bispectrum estimation. Acta Physica Sinica, 2010, 59(10): 7516-7522. doi: 10.7498/aps.59.7516
[11]	Pu Xiao-Yun, Bai Ran, Xiang Wen-Li, Du Fei, Jiang Nan. Two-wavelength-range whispering-gallery-mode fiber laser pumped by evanescent wave. Acta Physica Sinica, 2009, 58(6): 3923-3928. doi: 10.7498/aps.58.3923
[12]	Tang Shi-Wei, Zhu Wei-Ren, Zhao Xiao-Peng. Multiband negative index metamaterials at optical frequencies. Acta Physica Sinica, 2009, 58(5): 3220-3223. doi: 10.7498/aps.58.3220
[13]	Li Wei-Hu, Yuan Rong. Statistical characteristics of gamma ray and radio emission of BL Lac object. Acta Physica Sinica, 2009, 58(9): 6671-6676. doi: 10.7498/aps.58.6671
[14]	Liu Yun, Zhang Xiong, Zheng Yong-Gang, Wang Xiao-Min, Bao Yu-Ying. Polarization and variations of Blazar. Acta Physica Sinica, 2007, 56(9): 5558-5563. doi: 10.7498/aps.56.5558
[15]	Zhang Hao-Jing, Zhang Xiong. A study of the light curve periodic behavior of BL Lac object S5 0716+714. Acta Physica Sinica, 2007, 56(7): 4305-4311. doi: 10.7498/aps.56.4305
[16]	Cheng Yong, Zhang Xiong, Wu Lin, Mao Wei-Ming, You Li-Sha. Analysis of the correlation between γ-ray and radio emissions from γ-ray loud Blazar using the discrete correlation function. Acta Physica Sinica, 2006, 55(2): 988-994. doi: 10.7498/aps.55.988
[17]	Zhang Xiong, Yang Wei-Guo, Hou De-Dong, Hu Shao-Ming, Zheng Yong-Gang, Mao Wei-Ming. The characteristic optical variability and black hole for the H0323+022. Acta Physica Sinica, 2005, 54(6): 2961-2968. doi: 10.7498/aps.54.2961
[18]	ZHANG XIONG, XIE GUANG-ZHONG, ZHAO GANG, MA LI, YI JI-DONG, BAI JIN-MING. STUDY OF GAMMA-RAY AND NEAR-INFRARED EMISSION OF GAMMA-RAY-LOUD BLAZARS OBJECT. Acta Physica Sinica, 2001, 50(2): 354-360. doi: 10.7498/aps.50.354
[19]	. . Acta Physica Sinica, 2000, 49(2): 379-382. doi: 10.7498/aps.49.379
[20]	SHI YIN-HUAN, ZHAO BAI-RU, ZHAO YU-YING, LI LIN. THE PREPARATION AND PHYSICAL PROPERTIES OF B1 STRUCTURE MoNx THIN FILMS. Acta Physica Sinica, 1988, 37(7): 1089-1095. doi: 10.7498/aps.37.1089

Catalog

Vol. 59, Issue 5 - 2010-03-05

Metrics

Abstract views: 6955
PDF Downloads: 523
Cited By: 0

姓名
邮箱
手机号码
标题
留言内容
验证码

Search

Article

留言板