搜索

x

留言板

尊敬的读者、作者、审稿人, 关于本刊的投稿、审稿、编辑和出版的任何问题, 您可以本页添加留言。我们将尽快给您答复。谢谢您的支持!

姓名
邮箱
手机号码
标题
留言内容
验证码

核天体物理实验数据评价:现状与挑战

南威克 柳卫平 陈洁

引用本文:
Citation:

核天体物理实验数据评价:现状与挑战

南威克, 柳卫平, 陈洁

Evaluation of Experimental Data in Nuclear Astrophysics: Status and Challenges

NAN Weike, LIU Weiping, CHEN Jie
Article Text (iFLYTEK Translation)
PDF
导出引用
在线预览
  • 核反应率数据库是天体核合成与恒星演化建模的关键输入量,直接影响各类核天体物理过程的计算精度与物理可信度。近年来,高分辨4π探测器阵列、新型气体探测器、γ–带电粒子符合测量等先进实验技术在关键核天体物理反应研究中得到广泛应用;同时,锦屏深地核天体物理实验平台等地下低本底设施也取得了一系列重要进展。这些新的低能区实验测量结果,相较于传统数据库依赖的经验外推或者理论计算,为关键核反应天体环境温度区间的热核反应率评估提供了更直接的约束,也为未来数据库的持续优化提供了新的实验支撑。本文系统回顾了当前主流核反应率数据库——REACLIB、STARLIB、BRUSLIB等的建库目标、数据结构与典型应用,梳理了它们在数据库覆盖、拟合方式与误差评价等方面的特征。这些数据库在推动核反应网络计算标准化进程中发挥了重要作用。在此基础上,结合当前核反应率数据库特点,在元数据存储结构、数据库更新以及人员组织形式等方面提出若干方法,并强调了前沿实验进展对先进数据库构建的重要性。
    Nuclear reaction rate databases serve as essential inputs for nucleosynthesis and stellar evolution modeling, directly influencing the accuracy and physical reliability of calculations in various nuclear astrophysics processes. This work provides a comprehensive review of the major reaction rate databases— REACLIB, STARLIB, and BRUSLIB—highlighting their objectives, data structures, and representative applications, and discussing their coverage, fitting methods, and uncertainty evaluation. These databases have been instrumental in advancing the standardization of nuclear reaction network calculations. However, although these databases have significantly lowered the barrier to performing network modeling, there remains substantial room for improvement in aspects such as database unit structures, update mechanisms, and organizational frameworks. For example, detailed information on the underlying nuclear physics experiments or data analyses is often not included in REACLIB. Therefore, enhancing the stored metadata warrants careful consideration, since it can significantly improve the reliability of astrophysical modeling. At the same time, the advancement of nuclear astrophysics reaction rate databases depends heavily on continuous progress at the experimental frontier. In recent years, innovative experimental techniques—such as novel 4π high-resolution detector arrays and γ–charged particle coincidence measurements—have been widely applied to studies of key nuclear astrophysics reactions, significantly expanding research capabilities. To meet the demands of cutting-edge astrophysical studies for accurate reaction rates, the real-time updating and systematic evaluation of experimental data for key reactions represent both an important opportunity and an urgent challenge for the development of modern databases. several important achievements of the JUNA Collaboration at the Jinping underground nuclear astrophysics facility, where low-background experiments have been conducted, are also presented in this paper. These new low-energy measurements, when compared with traditional extrapolations used in databases, are found to provide more direct constraints on key reactions in nuclear astrophysics and to offer crucial experimental support for the continuous optimization of future databases.
  • [1]

    Pagel B 1980 Nature 286 744

    [2]

    Burbidge E M, Burbidge G R, Fowler W A, Hoyle F 1957 Rev. Mod. Phys. 29 547

    [3]

    Angulo C, Arnould M, Rayet M, Descouvemount P, Baye D, Willain C L, Coc A, Barhoumi S, Aguer P, Rolfs C, Kunz R, Hammer J W, Mayer A, Paradellis T, Kossionides S, Chronidou C, Spyrou K, Innocenti S D, Fiorentini G, Ricci B, Zavatarelli S, Providencia C, Wolters H, Soares J, Grama C, Rahighi J, Shotter A, Rachti M L 1999 Nucl. Phys. A 656 3

    [4]

    Werrison A W, Wiblin E R 1951 Nature 167 346

    [5]

    Fowler W A 1969 Eng. Sci. 32 8

    [6]

    Cease R P 2001 Hist. Stud. Phys. Biol. Sci. 32 41

    [7]

    Catherall R, Andreazza W, Breitenfeldt M, Dorsival A, Focker G J, Gharsa T P, Giles T J, Grenard J L, Locci F, Martins P, Marzari S, Schipper J, Shornikov A, Stora T 2017 J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 44 094002

    [8]

    Burkard K H, Dumanski W, Kirchner R, Klepper O, Roeckl E 1976 Nucl. Instrum. Methods 139 275

    [9]

    Macklin R L, Gibbons J H, Inada T 1963 Phys. Rev. 129 2695

    [10]

    Macklin R L, Gibbons J H, Inada T 1963 Nature 197 369

    [11]

    Lovell A C B, Wilson A, Wiblin D V M 1951 Nature 167 476

    [12]

    Zerkin V V, Pritychenko B 2018 Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 888 31

    [13]

    Otuka N, Dupont E, Semkova V, Pritychenko B, Blokhin A I, Aikawa M, Babykina S, Bossant M, Chen G, Dunaeva S, Forrest R A, Fukahori T, Furutachi N, Ganesan S, Ge Z, Gritzay O O, Herman M, Hlavac S, Kato K, Lalremruata B, Zhuang Y 2014 Nucl. Data Sheets 120 272

    [14]

    Cyburt R H, Amthor A M, Ferguson R, Meisel Z, Smith K, Warren S, Heger A, Hoffman R D, Rauscher T, Sakharuk A, Schatz H, Thielemann F K, Wiescher M 2010 Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 189 240

    [15]

    Aikawa M, Arnould M, Goriely S, Jorissen A, Takahashi K 2005 A & A 441 1195

    [16]

    Sallaska A L, Iliadis C, Champange A E, Goriely S, Starrfield S, Timmes F X 2013 Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 207 18

    [17]

    Fowler W A, Caughlan G E, Zimmerman B A 1967 Ann. Rev. Astr. Astro. 5 525

    [18]

    Xu Y, Goriely S, Jorissen A, Chen G L, Arnould M 2013 A & A 549 106

    [19]

    Fowler W A, Caughlan G R, Zimmerman B A 1975 Ann. Rev. Astr. Astro. 13 69

    [20]

    Harris M J, Fowler W A, Caughlan G R, Zimmerman B A 1983 Ann. Rev. Astr. Astro. 21 165

    [21]

    Caughlan G R, Fowler W A, Harris M J, Zimmerman B A 1985 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 32 197

    [22]

    Caughlan G R, Fowler W A, 1988 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 40 283

    [23]

    Rauscher T, Thielemann F -K 2000 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 75 1

    [24]

    Xu Y, Takahashi K, Goriely S, Arnould M, Ohta M, Utsunomiya H 2013 Nucl. Phys. A 918 61

    [25]

    Iliadis C, D’Auria J M, Starrfield S, Thompson W J, Wiescher M 2001 Astrophys. J. 134 151

    [26]

    Bao Z Y, Beer H, K̈appeler F, VOSS F, WISSHAK K 2000 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 76 70

    [27]

    Koning A J, Delaroche J-P 2003 Nucl. Phys. A 713 231

    [28]

    Demetriou P, Grama C, Goriely S 2002 Nucl. Phys. A 707 253

    [29]

    Longland R, Iliadis C, Champange A E, Newton J R, Ugalde C, Coc A, Fitzgerald R 2010 Nucl. Phys. A 841 1

    [30]

    Iliadis C, Longland R, Champange A E, Coc A, Fitzgerald R 2010 Nucl. Phys. A 841 31

    [31]

    Iliadis C, Longland R, Champange A E, Coc A 2010 Nucl. Phys. A 841 323

    [32]

    Iliadis C, Longland R, Champange A E, Coc A 2010 Nucl. Phys. A 841 251

    [33]

    Hix W R, Thielmann F K 1999 Astrophys. J. 511 862

    [34]

    Paxton B, Smolec R, Schwab J 2019 Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 243 10

    [35]

    Woosley S E, Heger A 2007 Phys. Rep. 442 269

    [36]

    Wagoner R V 1969 Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 162 247

    [37]

    Woosley S E, Fowler W A, Holmes J A, Zimmerman B A 1978 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 22 371

    [38]

    Dillmann I, Heil M, Käppeler F, Plag R, Rauscher T, Thielemann F-K 2006 Proceedings of the International Conference on Capture Gamma-Ray Spectroscopy and Related Topics Notre Dame, IN, USA, September 4–9, 2005 p123

    [39]

    Bao Z Y, Käppeler F 1987 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 36 411

    [40]

    Beer H, Voss F, Winters R R 1992 Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 80 403

    [41]

    Vescovi D, Reifarth R, Lorenz E, Elbe A 2023 EPJ Web Conf. 279 11011

    [42]

    Dillmann I, Plag R, Käppeler F, Rauscher T 2010 Proceedings of the Scientific Workshop on Neutron Measurements, Theory and Applications – Nuclear Data for Sustainable Nuclear Energy Geel, Belgium, April 28–30, 2009 p55

    [43]

    Reifarth R, Erbacher P, Fiebiger S, Göbel K, Heftrich T, Heil M, Käppeler F, Klapper N, Kurtulgil D, Langer C 2018 Eur. Phys. J. Plus 133 424

    [44]

    Rochman D, Koning A, Goriely S, Hilaire S 2025 Nucl. Phys. A 1053 122951

    [45]

    Rauscher T, Thielemann F K 2000 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 75 1

    [46]

    Okumura S, Schnabel G, Koning A 2024 EPJ Web Conf. 292 12003

    [47]

    Xu J Y, Yang L S, Li Q T, Ye Y L, Han J X, Bai S W, Gao J 2020 Atom. Energy Sci. Technol. 54 6 (in Chinese) [许金艳, 阳黎升, 李奇特,叶沿林,韩家兴,白世伟,高见 2020 原子能科学技术 54 6]

    [48]

    Lu F H, Tang S W, Fu S W, Yan D, Ma P, Yang H B, Yu Y H, Zhang X H, Wang S T, Zhang Y J, Fang F, Liu T Q, Xu Y F, Li Z, Liu X M, Wei X B, Sun Z Y 2024 Nucl. Phys. Rev. 32 3 (in Chinese) [卢奋华, 唐述文, 傅圣威,闫铎,马朋,杨海波,余玉洪,章学恒,王世陶,张永杰,方芳, 刘拓琦,徐颖锋,李治,刘相满,魏啸宝,孙志宇 2024 原子核物理评论 32 3]

    [49]

    Fan S N, Wang B, Qi H R, Liu M, Zhang Y L, Zhang J, Liu R G, Yi F T, Ouyang Q, Chen Y B 2013 Acta Phys. Sin. 62 122901 (in Chinese) [范胜男, 王波, 祁辉荣, 刘梅, 张余炼, 张建, 刘荣光, 伊 福廷, 欧阳群, 陈元柏 2013 物理学报 62 122901]

    [50]

    Wu Y J, Meng T M, Zhang X W, Tan X, Ma P F, Yin H, Ren B H, Tu B S. Zhang R T, Xiao J, Ma X W, Zou Y M, Wei B R 2024 Acta Phys. Sin. 73 240701 (in Chinese) [吴怡娇, 孟天鸣,张献 文,谭旭,马蒲芳,殷浩,任百惠,屠秉晟,张瑞天,肖君,马新文,邹亚明,魏宝仁 2024 物理学 报 73 240701]

    [51]

    Yang G C, Hua L M, Lu F, Su J, Li Z H, Jin S L, Shen Y P, Guo B 2022 Nucl. Sci. Tech. 33 68

    [52]

    Spyrou A, Richman D, Couture A, Fields C E, Liddick S N, Childers K, Crider B P, DeYoung P A, Dombos A C, Gastis P, Guttormsen M, Hermansen K, Larsen A C, Lewis R, Lyons S, Midtbø J E, Mosby S, Muecher D, Naqvi F, PalmisanoKyle A, Perdikakis G, Prokop C, Schatz H, Smith M K, Sumithrarachchi C, Sweet A 2024 Nat. Commun. 15 9608

    [53]

    Song L Y, Wang L, Su J, Zhang L Y, He J J, Jin S L, Lu F, Shen Y P, Chen J F, Sheng Y D, Chen X, Lin S, Qin Z W, Li Z M, Zhang H, Wang L H, Chen Y J, Jiang X Z, Shen Z L, Li X Y, Liu F C, Huang Y T, Chen S Z, Guo B, Liu W P 2025 Nucl. Sci. Tech. 36 213 24

    [54]

    Ayyad Y, Olaizola B, Mittig W, Potel G, Zelevinsky V, Horoi M, Beceiro-Novo S, Alcorta M, Andreoiu C, Ahn T, Anholm M, Atar L, Babu A, Bazin D, Bernier N, Bhattacharjee S S, Bowry M, Caballero-Folch R, Cortesi M, Dalitz C, Dunling E, Garnsworthy A B, Holl M, Kootte B, Leach K G, Randhawa J S, Saito Y, Santamaria C, Šiuryt˙e P, Svensson C E, Umashankar R, Watwood N, Yates D 2019 Phys. Rev. Lett. 123 082501

    [55]

    Sieverding A, Randhawa J S, Zetterberg D, deBoer R J, Ahn T, Mancino R, Martínez-Pinedo G, Hix W R 2022 Phys. Rev. C 106 015803

    [56]

    Hu J, Yamaguchi H, Lam Y H, Heger A, Kahl D, Jacobs A M, Johnston Z, Xu S W, Zhang N T, Ma S B, Ru L H, Liu E Q, Liu T, Hayakawa S, Yang L, Shimizu H, Hamill C B, Murphy A St J, Su J, Fang X, Chae K Y, Kwag M S, Cha S M, Duy N N, Uyen N K, Kim D H, Pizzone R G, La Cognata M, Cherubini S, Romano S, Tumino A, Liang J, Psaltis A, Sferrazza M, Kim D H, Li Y Y, Kubono S 2021 Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 172701

    [57]

    Gai M 2022 EPJ Web Conf. 260 01005

    [58]

    Ayyad Y, Bazin D, Bonaiti F, Chen J, Li X, Anthony A, Avila M, Beceiro-Novo S, Bhatt K, Cabo C, Furuno T, Guimarães V, Hall-Smith A, Hunt C, Jayatissa H, Kawabata T, Kumi H, LópezGonzález J M, Lois-Fuentes J, Macchiavelli A, McCann G, Müller-Gatermann C, Muñoz-Ramos A, Mittig W, Olaizola B, Rahman Z, Regueira D, Rufino J, Sakajo S, Santamaria C, Serikow M Z, Tang T, Tolstukhin I, Turi N, Watwood N, Zamora J 2025 Front. Phys. 13 1539148

    [59]

    Jiang Y, He Z, Luo Y, Xin W, Chen J, Li X, Shen Y, Guo B, Li G, Pang D, Ma T, Nan W, Kajino T, Liu W 2025 Astrophys. J. 989 231

    [60]

    Nan W K, Wang Y B, Sheng Y D, Su J, Zhang Y Q, Song L Y, Shen Y P, Cao F Q, Chen C, Dong C, Li Y J, Li Z H, Lian G, Nan W, Wang Q, Song N, Yan S Q, Zeng S, Fan Q W, Zhang H, Zhu M H, Guo B, Liu W P 2024 Nucl. Sci. Tech. 35 208

    [61]

    Nan W K, Wang Y B, Su J, Sheng Y D, deBoer R J, Zhang Y Q, Song L Y, Cao F Q, Chen C, Dong C, Li Y J, Li Z H, Lian G, Nan W, Shen Y P, Song N, Yan S Q, Zeng S, Guo B, Liu W P 2025 Phys. Lett. B 862 139341

    [62]

    Nan W K, Wang Y B, Shen Y P, Li Y J, Guo B, Liu W P 2025 Nucl. Phys. Rev. 42 199 (in Chinese) [南威克, 王友宝, 谌阳平,李云居,郭冰,柳卫平 2025 原子核物理评论 42 199]

    [63]

    Tumino A, Spitaleri C, La Cognata M, Cherubini S, Guardo G L, Gulino M, Hayakawa S, Indelicato I, Lamia L, Petrascu H, Pizzone R G, Puglia S M R, Rapisarda G G, Romano S, Sergi M L, Spartá R, Trache L 2018 Nature 557 687

    [64]

    deBoer R J, Görres J, Wiescher M, Azuma R E, Best A, Brune C R, Fields C E, Jones S, Pignatari M, Sayre D, Smith K, Timmes F X, Uberseder E 2017 Rev. Mod. Phys. 89 035007

    [65]

    Wang Y B, Qin X, Wang B X, Liu W P, Li Z H, Bai X X, Lian G, Guo B, Zeng S, Su J, Li Y J, Jiang C 2009 Chin. Phys. C 33 181

    [66]

    Qin X, Wang Y B, Bai X X, Guo B, Jiang C, Li Y J, Li Z H, Lian G, Su J, Wang B X, Zeng S, Liu W P 2008 Chin. Phys. C 32 957

    [67]

    Broggini C, Bemmerer D, Caciolli A, Trezzi D 2018 Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 98 55

    [68]

    Robertson D, Couder M, Greife U, Strieder F, Wiescher M 2016 EPJ Web Conf. 109 09002

    [69]

    Liu W P, Li Z H, He J J, Tang X D, Lian G, An Z, Chang J J, Chen H, Chen Q H, Chen X J, Chen Z J, Cui B Q, Du X C, Fu C B, Gan L, Guo B, He G Z, Heger A, Hou S Q, Huang H X, Huang N, Jia B L, Jiang L Y, Kubono S, Li J M, Li K A, Li T, Li Y J, Lugaro M, Luo X B, Ma H Y, Ma S B, Mei D M, Qian Y Z, Qin J C, Ren J, Shen Y P, Su J, Sun L T, Tan W P, Tanihata I, Wang S, Wang P, Wang Y B, Wu Q, Xu S W, Yan S Q, Yang L T, Yang Y, Yu X Q, Yue Q, Zeng S, Zhang H Y, Zhang H, Zhang L Y, Zhang N T, Zhang Q W, Zhang T, Zhang X P, Zhang X Z, Zhang Z M, Zhao W, Zhao Z, Zhou C 2016 Sci. China Phys. Mech. Astron. 59 642001

    [70]

    Liu W P 2023 Chin. Phys. Lett. 40 060401

    [71]

    Mossa V, Stöckel K, Cavanna F, Ferraro F, Aliotta M, Barile F, Bemmerer D, Best A, Boeltzig A, Broggini C, Bruno C G, Caciolli A, Chillery T, Ciani G F, Corvisiero P, Csedreki L, Davinson T, Depalo R, Di Leva A, Elekes Z, Fiore E M, Formicola A, Fülöp Zs, Gervino G, Guglielmetti A, Gustavino C, Gyürky G, Imbriani G, Junker M, Kievsky A, Kochanek I, Lugaro M, Marcucci L E, Mangano G, Marigo P, Masha E, Menegazzo R, Pantaleo F R, Paticchio V, Perrino R, Piatti D, Pisanti O, Prati P, Schiavulli L, Straniero O, Szücs T, Takács M P, Trezzi D, Viviani M, Zavatarelli S 2020 Nature 587 210

    [72]

    Piatti D, Chillery T, Depalo R, Aliotta M, Bemmerer D, Best A, Boeltzig A, Broggini C, Bruno C G, Caciolli A, Cavanna F, Ciani G F, Corvisiero P, Csedreki L, Davinson T, Di Leva A, Elekes Z, Ferraro F, Fiore E M, Formicola A, Fülöp Zs, Gervino G, Gnech A, Guglielmetti A, Gustavino C, Gyürky Gy, Imbriani G, Junker M, Kochanek I, Lugaro M, Marcucci L E, Marigo P, Masha E, Menegazzo R, Mossa V, Pantaleo F R, Paticchio V, Perrino R, Prati P, Schiavulli L, Stöckel K, Straniero O, Szücs T, Takács M P, Zavatarelli S 2020 Phys. Rev. C 102 052802(R)

    [73]

    Skowronski J, Boeltzig A, Ciani G F, Csedreki L, Piatti D, Aliotta M, Ananna C, Barile F, Bemmerer D, Best A, Broggini C, Bruno C G, Caciolli A, Campostrini M, Cavanna F, Colombetti P, Compagnucci A, Corvisiero P, Davinson T, Depalo R, Di Leva A, Elekes Z, Ferraro F, Formicola A, Fülöp Zs, Gervino G, Gesuè R M, Guglielmetti A, Gustavino C, Gyürky Gy, Imbriani G, Junker M, Lugaro M, Marigo P, Masha E, Menegazzo R, Paticchio V, Perrino R, Prati P, Rapagnani D, Rigato V, Schiavulli L, Sidhu R S, Straniero O, Szücs T, Zavatarelli S 2023 Phys. Rev. Lett. 131 162701

    [74]

    Pantaleo F R, Boeltzig A, Best A, Perrino R, Aliotta M, Balibrea-Correa J, Barile F, Bemmerer D, Broggini C, Bruno C G, Buompane R, Caciolli A, Cavanna F, Chillery T, Ciani G F, Corvisiero P, Csedreki L, Davinson T, deBoer R J, Depalo R, D’Erasmo G, Di Leva A, Elekes Z, Ferraro F, Fiore E M, Formicola A, Fülöp Zs, Gervino G, Guglielmetti A, Gustavino C, Gyürky Gy, Imbriani G, Junker M, Kochanek I, Lugaro M, Masha E, Menegazzo R, Mossa V, Paticchio V, Piatti D, Prati P, Rapagnani D, Schiavulli L, Stöckel K, Straniero O, Szücs T, Takács M P, Trezzi D, Wiescher M, Zavatarelli S 2021 Phys. Rev. C 104 025802

    [75]

    Piatti D, Masha E, Aliotta M, Balibrea-Correa J, Barile F, Bemmerer D, Best A, Boeltzig A, Broggini C, Bruno C G, Caciolli A, Cavanna F, Chillery T, Ciani G F, Compagnucci A, Corvisiero P, Csedreki L, Davinson T, Depalo R, Di Leva A, Elekes Z, Ferraro F, Fiore E M, Formicola A, Fülöp Zs, Gervino G, Guglielmetti A, Gustavino C, Gyürky Gy, Imbriani G, Junker M, Lugaro M, Marigo P, Menegazzo R, Mossa V, Pantaleo F R, Paticchio V, Perrino R, Prati P, Rapagnani D, Schiavulli L, Skowronski J, Stöckel K, Straniero O, Szücs T, Takács M P, Zavatarelli S 2022 Eur. Phys. J. A 58 194

    [76]

    Ciani G F, Csedreki L, Rapagnani D, Aliotta M, Balibrea-Correa J, Barile F, Bemmerer D, Best A, Boeltzig A, Broggini C, Bruno C G, Caciolli A, Cavanna F, Chillery T, Colombetti P, Corvisiero P, Cristallo S, Davinson T, Depalo R, Di Leva A, Elekes Z, Ferraro F, Fiore E, Formicola A, Fülöp Zs, Gervino G, Guglielmetti A, Gustavino C, Gyürky Gy, Imbriani G, Junker M, Lugaro M, Marigo P, Masha E, Menegazzo R, Mossa V, Pantaleo F R, Paticchio V, Perrino R, Piatti D, Prati P, Schiavulli L, Stöckel K, Straniero O, Szücs T, Takács M P, Terrasi F, Vescovi D, Zavatarelli S 2021 Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 152701

    [77]

    Dombos A C, Robertson D, Simon A, Kadlecek T, Hanhardt M, Görres J, Couder M, Kelmar R, Olivas-Gomez O, Stech E, Strieder F, Wiescher M 2022 Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 162701

    [78]

    Straniero O, Imbriani G, Strieder F, Bemmerer D, Broggini C, Caciolli A, Corvisiero P, Costantini H, Cristallo S, Di Leva A, Formicola A, Elekes Z, Fülöp Zs, Gervino G, Guglielmetti A, Gustavino C, Gyürky Gy, Junker M, Lemut A, Limata B, Marta M, Mazzocchi C, Menegazzo R, Piersanti L, Prati P, Roca V, Rolfs C, Rossi Alvarez C, Somorjai E, Terrasi F, Trautvetter H-P 2013 Astrophys. J. 763 100

    [79]

    Su J, Zhang H, Li Z H, Ventura P, Li Y J, Li E, Chen C, Shen Y P, Lian G, Guo B, Li X Y, Zhang L Y, He J J, Shen Y D, Chen Y J, Wang L H, Zhang L, Cao F Q, Nan W, Nan W K, Li G X, Song N, Cui B Q, Chen L H, Ma R G, Zhang Z C, Jiao T Y, Gao B S, Tang X D, Wu Q, Li J Q, Sun L T, Wang S, Yan S Q, Liao J H, Wang Y B, Zeng S, Nan D, Fan Q W, Qi N C, Sun W L, Guo X Y, Zhang P, Chen Y H, Zhou Y, Zhou J F, He J R, Shang C S, Li M C, Cheng J P, Liu W P 2022 Sci. Bull. 67 125

    [80]

    Gao B, Jiao T Y, Li Y T, Chen H, Lin W P, An Z, Ru L H, Zhang Z C, Tang X D, Wang X Y, Zhang N T, Fang X, Xie D H, Fan Y H, Ma L, Zhang X, Bai F, Wang P, Fan Y X, Liu G, Huang H X, Wu Q, Zhu Y B, Chai J L, Li J Q, Sun L T, Wang S, Cai J W, Li Y Z, Su J, Zhang H, Li Z H, Li Y J, Li E T, Chen C, Shen Y P, Lian G, Guo B, Li X Y, Zhang L Y, He J J, Sheng Y D, Chen Y J, Wang L H, Zhang L, Cao F Q, Nan W, Nan W K, Li G X, Song N, Cui B Q, Chen L H, Ma R G, Zhang Z C, Yan S Q, Liao J H, Wang Y B, Zeng S, Nan D, Fan Q W, Qi N C, Sun W L, Guo X Y, Zhang P, Chen Y H, Zhou Y, Zhou J F, He J R, Shang C S, Li M C, Kubono S, Liu W P, deBoer R J, Wiescher M, Pignatari M 2022 Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 132701

    [81]

    Zhang L Y, He J J, deBoer R J, Wiescher M, Heger A, Kahl D, Su J, Odell D, Chen Y J, Li X Y, Wang J G, Zhang L, Cao F Q, Zhang H, Zhang Z C, Jiang X Z, Wang L H, Li Z M, Song L Y, Zhao H W, Sun L T, Wu Q, Li J Q, Cui B Q, Chen L H, Ma R G, Li E T, Lian G, Sheng Y D, Li Z H, Guo B, Zhou X H, Zhang Y H, Xu H S, Cheng J P, Liu W P 2022 Nature 610 656

    [82]

    Zhang L Y, Su J, He J J, Wiescher M, deBoer R J, Kahl D, Chen Y J, Li X Y, Wang J G, Zhang L, Cao F Q, Zhang H, Zhang Z C, Jiao T Y, Sheng Y D, Wang L H, Song L Y, Jiang X Z, Li Z M, Li E T, Wang S, Lian G, Li Z H, Tang X D, Zhao H W, Sun L T, Wu Q, Li J Q, Cui B Q, Chen L H, Ma R G, Guo B, Xu S W, Li J Y, Qi N C, Sun W L, Guo X Y, Zhang P, Chen Y H, Zhou Y, Zhou J F, He J R, Shang C S, Li M C, Zhou X H, Zhang Y H, Zhang F S, Hu Z G, Xu H S, Chen J P, Liu W P 2022 Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 152702

    [83]

    Wang L H, Su J, Shen Y P, He J J, Lugaro M, Szányi B, Karakas A I, Zhang L Y, Li X Y, Guo B, Lian G, Li Z H, Wang Y B, Chen L H, Cui B Q, Tang X D, Gao B S, Wu Q, Sun L T, Wang S, Sheng Y D, Chen Y J, Zhang H, Li Z M, Song L Y, Jiang X Z, Nan W, Nan W K, Zhang L, Cao F Q, Jiao T Y, Ru L H, Cheng J P, Wiescher M, Liu W P 2023 Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 092701

    [84]

    Liu W P, Guo B, An Z, Cui B Q, Fang X, Fu C B, Gao B S, He J J, Jiang Y C, Lv C, Li E T, Li G X, Li Y J, Li Z H, Lian G, Lin W P, Liu Y H, Nan W, Nan W K, Shen Y P, Song N, Su J, Sun L T, Tang X D, Wang L H, Wang S, Wang Y B, Wu D, Xi X F, Yan S Q, Zhang L Y 2024 Nucl. Sci. Tech. 35 217

    [85]

    Randhawa J S, Ayyad Y, Mittig W, Meisel Z, Ahn T, Aguilar S, Alvarez-Pol H, Bardayan D W, Bazin D, Beceiro-Novo S, Blankstein D, Carpenter L, Cortesi M, Cortina-Gil D, Gastis P, Hall M, Henderson S, Kolata J J, Mijatovic T, Ndayisabye F, O’Malley P, Pereira J, Pierre A, Robert H, Santamaria C, Schatz H, Smith J, Watwood N, Zamora J C 2020 Phys. Rev. Lett. 125 202701

    [86]

    Nan W, Shen Y P, Guo B, Li Z H, Li Y J, Pang D Y, Su J, Yan S Q, Fan Q W, Liu J C, Chen C, Li X Y, Lian G, Ma T L, Nan W K, Wang Y B, Zeng S, Zhang H, Liu W P 2024 Phys. Rev. C 109 045808

    [87]

    Shen Y P, Guo B, deBoer R J, Li Z H, Li Y J, Tang X D, Pang D Y, Adhikari S, Basu C, Su J, Yan S Q, Fan Q W, Liu J C, Chen C, Han Z Y, Li X Y, Lian G, Ma T L, Nan W, Nan W K, Wang Y B, Zeng S, Zhang H, Liu W P 2022 Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 162701

    [88]

    Wiescher M, deBoer R J, Görres J 2023 Eur. Phys. J. A 59 11

    [89]

    Longland R, Dermigny J, Marshall C 2018 Phys. Rev. C 98 025802

    [90]

    Mohr P, Longland R, Iliadis C 2014 Phys. Rev. C 90 065806

    [91]

    Wallner A, Bichler M, Coquard L, Dillmann I, Forstner O, Golser R, Heil M, Käppeler F, Kutschera W, Lederer-Woods C, Martschini M, Mengoni A, Merchel S, Michlmayr L, Priller A, Steier P, Wiescher M 2019 Phys. Rev. C 99 015804

    [92]

    Dermigny J, Iliadis C, Champagne A, Longland R 2020 Phys. Rev. C 102 014609

    [93]

    Bao Z Y, Beer H, Käppeler F, Voss F, Wisshak K, Rauscher T 2000 At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 76 70

    [94]

    Zhou Y, Li Z H, Zhang H Q 2015 Atom. Energy Sci. Technol. 11 1921 (in Chinese)[周勇, 李志宏, 张 海黔 2015 原子能科学技术 11 1921]

  • [1] 邓祥泉, 周善贵. 基于双核模型的超重原子核合成截面系统研究. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.75.20251309
    [2] 陈胜利, 王天翔. 两个系列铍反射层临界基准实验的一致性分析与核数据检验. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.74.20241685
    [3] 徐佳伟, 许传喜, 张瑞田, 朱小龙, 冯文天, 赵冬梅, 梁贵云, 郭大龙, 高永, 张少锋, 苏茂根, 马新文. 态选择电荷交换实验测量以及对天体物理软X射线发射模型的检验. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.70.20201685
    [4] 吴思远, 王宇琦, 肖睿娟, 陈立泉. 电池材料数据库的发展与应用. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.69.20201542
    [5] 龚武坤, 郭文军. 混合中子星内强子-夸克退禁闭相变. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.69.20200925
    [6] 何学敏, 钟伟, 都有为. 核壳结构磁性复合纳米材料的可控合成与性能. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.67.20181027
    [7] 李志文, 何学敏, 颜士明, 宋雪银, 乔文, 张星, 钟伟, 都有为. -Fe2O3/NiO核-壳纳米花的合成、微结构与磁性. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.65.147101
    [8] 裴晓星, 仲佳勇, 张凯, 郑无敌, 梁贵云, 王菲鹿, 李玉同, 赵刚. 实验室天体物理的验证特例:W43A磁喷流. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.63.145201
    [9] 黄小林, 侯丽珍, 喻博闻, 陈国良, 王世良, 马亮, 刘新利, 贺跃辉. Cu/C核/壳纳米结构的气相合成、形成机理及其光学性能研究. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.62.108102
    [10] 董建敏, 李君清, 苏昕宁, 王艳召, 张鸿飞, 左维. 致密天体中电子气体对原子核结构的影响. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.58.2294
    [11] 胡正国, 王 猛, 徐瑚珊, 孙志宇, 王建松, 肖国青, 詹文龙, 肖志刚, 毛瑞士, 张宏斌, 赵铁成, 徐治国, 王 玥, 陈若富, 黄天衡, 高 辉, 贾 飞, 付 芬, 高 启, 韩建龙. 丰中子奇异核17B的实验研究. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.57.2866
    [12] 黄明辉, 甘再国, 范红梅, 苏朋源, 马 龙, 周小红, 李君清. 超重核合成时的驱动势与热熔合反应截面. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.57.1569
    [13] 贾 飞, 徐瑚珊, 郑 川, 樊瑞睿, 张雪荧, 李君清, W. Scheid. 基于双核模型对超重元素合成机制的研究. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.56.2047
    [14] 刘建业, 左 维, 李希国, 邢永忠. 中子晕核引起核反应中的同位旋效应. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.56.1339
    [15] 李加兴, 郭忠言, 肖国青, 詹文龙, 王建松, 孙志宇, 王猛, 田文栋, 王武生, 毛瑞士, 王全进, 宁振江, 王建峰. 利用改进的Glauber模型对非奇异核核反应总截面数据的拟合. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.52.58
    [16] 夏江帆, 张军, 张杰. 用激光等离子体实验对天体物理动力学过程进行模拟的可行性研究. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.50.994
    [17] 宁振江, 李加兴, 郭忠言, 詹文龙, 王建松, 肖国青, 王全进, 王金川, 王猛, 王建峰, 陈志强. 质子滴线核12N在28Si靶上的核反应总截面测量. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.50.644
    [18] 缪竞威, 师勉恭, 杨百方, 唐阿友, N.Cue. 4HeH+核间距的实验测定. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.49.1058
    [19] 杨澄中. 原子核反应和核结构. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.18.275
    [20] 王德焴, 丘锡钧, 赵玄, 李白文, 陈金全. 关于低能核反应中的复合核效应. 物理学报, doi: 10.7498/aps.18.227
计量
  • 文章访问数:  15
  • PDF下载量:  0
  • 被引次数: 0
出版历程
  • 上网日期:  2025-11-12

/

返回文章
返回