Reliable identification of crystal defects in molecular dynamics simulations is essential for understanding deformation and fracture at elevated temperatures. The centrosymmetry parameter (CSP) is widely used for this purpose, but its reliability can deteriorate in bodycentered cubic (BCC) crystals under strong thermal fluctuations. The distance between the second- and first-neighbor shells in an ideal BCC lattice differs by only about 15.5%. Thermal fluctuations can reverse the instantaneous distance ordering of atoms in these shells, causing a second neighbor to be selected in place of a first neighbor. Minimum-weight matching (MWM) improves the pairing of selected neighbors but does not prevent this selection error. Here, we examine this failure mechanism and propose an ideal-neighbor approximation (INA) for CSP calculation. For each central atom, candidates within a cutoff sphere are assigned to the eight inversion-symmetric sites of an oriented ideal BCC template according to their geometric deviations. The candidate closest to each site is retained, and opposite template sites define the pairs used to calculate CSP. Radial distribution functions for α-Fe show overlap between the first two neighbor shells at elevated temperatures. Molecular dynamics simulations further reveal spurious, discrete high-CSP bands in thermally fluctuating BCC crystals. In defect-free α-Fe between 100 and 1200 K, INA-CSP instead produces a compact, unimodal distribution. From 300 to 1200 K, its standard deviation increases gradually with temperature, whereas that of MWM-CSP rises sharply. In an α-Fe bicrystal at 600 K, INA-CSP maintains a low-CSP background in the grain interiors while distinguishing the grain boundary and free surfaces. In a pre-cracked α-Fe crystal subjected to Mode I tension at 900 K, it reduces high-CSP artifacts in the far-field crystal and improves the visibility of the crack-tip region and newly formed surfaces. These results show that template-guided neighbor selection reduces thermally induced misidentification in the BCC systems examined. In amorphous or severely distorted regions, INA-CSP should be combined with independent structural analysis because the BCC template may no longer be valid. Within regions that retain recognizable BCC order, INA-CSP provides a more reliable tool for studying defect evolution during high-temperature deformation and fracture.