-
With excellent physical, mechanical and processing properties, silicon carbide (SiC) has gradually become a preferred lightweight optical material for primary mirrors of large space optical systems. The subsurface defects generated during the preparation and processing procedures of SiC will affect the optical quality of the primary mirrors and the imaging performance of the corresponding optical systems employing the SiC primary mirror as well. In this work, photothermal radiation (PTR), a powerful nondestructive testing technique for detecting sub-surface defects of solid materials, is employed to characterize the subsurface defects of bulk SiC material for primary mirrors. Theoretically, three-dimensional one-layer and three-layer PTR theoretical models are developed to describe the defect-free and defect regions of an SiC bulk material. By analyzing the frequency dependence of PTR phase of the SiC bulk material with different defect depths, an empirical formula for estimating the defect depth via a characteristic frequency (appearing at the minimum of the PTR phase-frequency curve) defined thermal diffusion length is proposed, and simulation results show reasonably good agreement between the estimated and simulated defect depths in a depth range of 0.05–0.50 mm. Experimentally, an SiC bulk sample with a subsurface defect region is tested by the PTR via position scanning and modulation frequency scanning to obtain the position and frequency dependent PTR amplitude and phase. From the spatial distributions of PTR amplitude and phase measured at different frequencies and the phase difference frequency curves of measurement positions in the defect region, the depth and shape of the defect region are estimated and found to be in good agreement with the actual shape of the defect region, which is destructively measured via a depth profiler. The experimental and calculated results demonstrate that the PTR is capable of detecting non-destructively the subsurface defects of SiC bulk material. In addition, for subsurface defects with relatively flat interface, the defect depth can be determined accurately by the developed empirical formula. -
Keywords:
- SiC /
- subsurface defects /
- photothermal radiometry
[1] Jiang F, Liu Y, Yang Y, Huang Z R, Li D, Liu G L, Liu X J 2012 J. Nano Mater. 2012 7
Google Scholar
[2] 韩媛媛, 张宇民, 韩杰才, 张剑寒, 姚旺, 周玉峰 2005 材料工程 06 59
Google Scholar
Han Y Y, Zhang Y M, Han J C, Zhang J H, Yao W, Zhou Y F 2005 J. Mater. Eng. 06 59
Google Scholar
[3] Sein E, Toulemont Y, Safa F, Duran M, Deny P, Chambure D, Passvogel T, Pilbratt G L 2003 SPIE IR Space Telescopes and Instruments 4850 606
Google Scholar
[4] Rodolfo J P 2008 SPIE Advanced Optical and Mechanical Technologies in Telescopes and Instrumentation 7018 70180E
Google Scholar
[5] Kaneda H, Nakagawa T, Onaka T, Enya K, Kataza H, Makiuti S, Matsuhara H, Miyamoto M, Murakami H, Saruwatari H, Watarai H, Yui Y Y 2007 SPIE Optical Materials and Structures Technologies III 6666 666607
Google Scholar
[6] Ebizuka N, Dai Y, Eto H, Lin W, Ebisuzaki T, Omori H, Handa T, Takami H, Takahashi Y 2003 SPIE Specialized Optical Developments in Astronomy 4842 329
Google Scholar
[7] 周岩 2020 硕士学位论文 (长春: 长春工业大学)
Zhou Y 2020 M. S. Thesis (Changchun: Changchun University of Technology) (in Chinese)
[8] Goela J S, Pickering M A, Tayler R L 1991 SPIE Optical Surfaces Resistant to Severe Environments 1330 25
Google Scholar
[9] Zappellini G B, Martin H M, Miller S M, Smith B K, Cuerden B, Gasho V, Sosa R G, Montoya M, Riccardi A 2007 SPIE Astronomical Adaptive Optics Systems and Applications III 6991 66910U
Google Scholar
[10] Xie J, Li Q, Sun J X, Li Y H 2015 J. Mater. Process. Tech. 222 422
Google Scholar
[11] Yoo H K, Ko J H, Lim K Y, Kwon W T, Kim Y W 2015 Ceram. Int. 41 3490
Google Scholar
[12] 李改灵, 孙开元, 冯仁余, 刘永军, 常林枫 2008 煤矿机械 12 99
Google Scholar
Li G L, Sun K Y, Feng R Y, Liu Y J, Chang L F 2008 Coal Mine Machinery 12 99
Google Scholar
[13] Neauport J, Ambard C, Cormont P, Darbois N, Destribats J, Luitot C, Rondeau O 2009 Opt. Express 17 20448
Google Scholar
[14] Fahnle O W, Wons T, Koch E, Debruyne S, Meeder M, Booij S M, Braat J J M 2002 Applied Optics 41 4036
Google Scholar
[15] Wuttig A, Steinert J, Duparre A, Truckenbrodt H 1999 SPIE Optical Fabrication and Testing 3739 369
Google Scholar
[16] 刘红婕, 王凤蕊, 耿峰, 周晓燕, 黄进, 叶鑫, 蒋晓东, 吴卫东, 杨李茗 2020 光学精密工程 28 50
Google Scholar
Liu H J, Wang F R, Geng F, Zhou X Y, Huang J, Ye X, Jiang X D, Wu W D, Yang L M 2020 Optics Precis. Eng. 28 50
Google Scholar
[17] Nordal P E, Kanstad S O 1979 Phys. Scr. 20 659
Google Scholar
[18] Nakamura H, Tsubouchi K, Mikoshiba N 1985 Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 24 222
Google Scholar
[19] 李佩赞 1989 红外技术 11 97
Li P Z 1989 Infrared Technology 11 97
[20] 范春利, 孙丰瑞, 杨立 2005 激光与红外 35 504
Google Scholar
Fan C L, Sun F R, Yang L 2005 Laser & Infrared 35 504
Google Scholar
[21] 王心觉, 刘恒彪, 胡文祥 2017 激光与光电子学进展 54 101201
[22] 曹丹, 屈惠明 2013 激光与红外 43 513
Cao D, Qu H M 2013 Laser & Infrared 43 513
[23] Muramatsu M, Nakasumi S, Harada Y 2016 Adv. Compos. Mater. 25 541
Google Scholar
[24] 马晓波, 王青青 2018 红外技术 40 85
Ma X B, Wang Q Q 2018 Infrared Technology 40 85
[25] 尹国应, 李爱珠 2020 光学与光电技术 18 18
Yin G Y, Li A Z 2020 Optics & Optoelectronic Technology 18 18
[26] 李佩赞, 王钦华 1994 仪器仪表学报 15 265
Google Scholar
Li P Z, Wang Q H 1994 Chin. J. Sci. Instrum. 15 265
Google Scholar
[27] 管国兴, 郑小明, 李佩赞 1988 红外研究 7A 201
Guan G X, Zheng X M, Li P Z 1988 Chin. J. Infrared Res. 7A 201
[28] 李佩赞, 王钦华 1996 物理 25 426
Li P Z, Wang Q H 1996 Physics 25 426
[29] 江海军, 陈力, 张淑仪 2014 无损检测 36 20
Jiang H J, Chen L, Zhang S Y 2014 Nondestructive Testing 36 20
[30] 江海军, 陈力, 苏清风, 邢建湘 2018 无损检测 40 15
Google Scholar
Jiang H J, Chen L, Su Q F, Xing J X 2018 Nondestructive Testing 40 15
Google Scholar
[31] 江海军, 陈力 2018 红外技术 40 946
Google Scholar
Jiang H J, Chen L 2018 Infrared Technology 40 946
Google Scholar
-
图 1 PTR理论模型 (a) 单层模型; (b) 三层模型
Figure 1. Configuration of PTR theoretical model: (a) One-layer model; (b) three-layer model.
图 2 不同缺陷深度下的PTR相位差-频率曲线
Figure 2. Phase difference-frequency curve of PTR signal in different defect depths.
图 3 缺陷深度计算结果 (a) 计算值与实际值比较; (b) 相对误差随深度的变化
Figure 3. Calculation results of depth of defect: (a) Comparison between calculated value and actual value; (b) relative error of different depths.
图 4 PTR实验装置
Figure 4. PTR experimental setup.
图 6 样品无缺陷区域PTR信号的实验结果及其最佳拟合曲线 (a) 幅度; (b)相位
Figure 6. Experimental frequency dependence of PTR signal and corresponding best-fit for the defect-free region of the SiC sample: (a) Amplitude; (b) phase.
图 7 SiC样品不同频率(5, 37, 245和960 Hz)时缺陷区域PTR信号的二维分布 (a) 幅度比; (b) 相位差
Figure 7. Two-dimensional spatial distributions of PTR signals measured at different modulation frequencies (5, 37, 245, and 960 Hz, respectively) for the defect region of the SiC sample: (a) Amplitude ratio; (b) phase difference.
图 8 (a) 实际的缺陷深度分布; (b) 部分测量点的PTR信号相位差-频率曲线
Figure 8. (a) Actual depth distribution of the defect region; (b) phase difference frequency curves of PTR signals at some measuring points.
表 1 测量点的缺陷深度估算结果
Table 1. Estimated results of defect depth at measuring points.
点 坐标 缺陷深度/μm 误差 实际值 测量值 绝对误差/μm 相对误差/% 1 (21.0, 19.0) 371.6 392.0 20.4 5.5 2 (20.5, 19.5) 392.0 392.0 0 0 3 (20.2, 20.0) 291.0 276.0 15.0 5.2 4 (20.0, 20.4) 186.9 164.0 22.9 12.3 5 (21.3, 17.2) 80.9 58.5 21.7 27.7 6 (21.0, 18.1) 284.0 392.0 108.0 38.1 7 (20.6, 19.1) 413.9 560.0 146.0 35.5 8 (19.8, 20.8) 118.0 58.5 59.5 50.4 
DownLoad: CSV
-
[1] Jiang F, Liu Y, Yang Y, Huang Z R, Li D, Liu G L, Liu X J 2012 J. Nano Mater. 2012 7
Google Scholar
[2] 韩媛媛, 张宇民, 韩杰才, 张剑寒, 姚旺, 周玉峰 2005 材料工程 06 59
Google Scholar
Han Y Y, Zhang Y M, Han J C, Zhang J H, Yao W, Zhou Y F 2005 J. Mater. Eng. 06 59
Google Scholar
[3] Sein E, Toulemont Y, Safa F, Duran M, Deny P, Chambure D, Passvogel T, Pilbratt G L 2003 SPIE IR Space Telescopes and Instruments 4850 606
Google Scholar
[4] Rodolfo J P 2008 SPIE Advanced Optical and Mechanical Technologies in Telescopes and Instrumentation 7018 70180E
Google Scholar
[5] Kaneda H, Nakagawa T, Onaka T, Enya K, Kataza H, Makiuti S, Matsuhara H, Miyamoto M, Murakami H, Saruwatari H, Watarai H, Yui Y Y 2007 SPIE Optical Materials and Structures Technologies III 6666 666607
Google Scholar
[6] Ebizuka N, Dai Y, Eto H, Lin W, Ebisuzaki T, Omori H, Handa T, Takami H, Takahashi Y 2003 SPIE Specialized Optical Developments in Astronomy 4842 329
Google Scholar
[7] 周岩 2020 硕士学位论文 (长春: 长春工业大学)
Zhou Y 2020 M. S. Thesis (Changchun: Changchun University of Technology) (in Chinese)
[8] Goela J S, Pickering M A, Tayler R L 1991 SPIE Optical Surfaces Resistant to Severe Environments 1330 25
Google Scholar
[9] Zappellini G B, Martin H M, Miller S M, Smith B K, Cuerden B, Gasho V, Sosa R G, Montoya M, Riccardi A 2007 SPIE Astronomical Adaptive Optics Systems and Applications III 6991 66910U
Google Scholar
[10] Xie J, Li Q, Sun J X, Li Y H 2015 J. Mater. Process. Tech. 222 422
Google Scholar
[11] Yoo H K, Ko J H, Lim K Y, Kwon W T, Kim Y W 2015 Ceram. Int. 41 3490
Google Scholar
[12] 李改灵, 孙开元, 冯仁余, 刘永军, 常林枫 2008 煤矿机械 12 99
Google Scholar
Li G L, Sun K Y, Feng R Y, Liu Y J, Chang L F 2008 Coal Mine Machinery 12 99
Google Scholar
[13] Neauport J, Ambard C, Cormont P, Darbois N, Destribats J, Luitot C, Rondeau O 2009 Opt. Express 17 20448
Google Scholar
[14] Fahnle O W, Wons T, Koch E, Debruyne S, Meeder M, Booij S M, Braat J J M 2002 Applied Optics 41 4036
Google Scholar
[15] Wuttig A, Steinert J, Duparre A, Truckenbrodt H 1999 SPIE Optical Fabrication and Testing 3739 369
Google Scholar
[16] 刘红婕, 王凤蕊, 耿峰, 周晓燕, 黄进, 叶鑫, 蒋晓东, 吴卫东, 杨李茗 2020 光学精密工程 28 50
Google Scholar
Liu H J, Wang F R, Geng F, Zhou X Y, Huang J, Ye X, Jiang X D, Wu W D, Yang L M 2020 Optics Precis. Eng. 28 50
Google Scholar
[17] Nordal P E, Kanstad S O 1979 Phys. Scr. 20 659
Google Scholar
[18] Nakamura H, Tsubouchi K, Mikoshiba N 1985 Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 24 222
Google Scholar
[19] 李佩赞 1989 红外技术 11 97
Li P Z 1989 Infrared Technology 11 97
[20] 范春利, 孙丰瑞, 杨立 2005 激光与红外 35 504
Google Scholar
Fan C L, Sun F R, Yang L 2005 Laser & Infrared 35 504
Google Scholar
[21] 王心觉, 刘恒彪, 胡文祥 2017 激光与光电子学进展 54 101201
[22] 曹丹, 屈惠明 2013 激光与红外 43 513
Cao D, Qu H M 2013 Laser & Infrared 43 513
[23] Muramatsu M, Nakasumi S, Harada Y 2016 Adv. Compos. Mater. 25 541
Google Scholar
[24] 马晓波, 王青青 2018 红外技术 40 85
Ma X B, Wang Q Q 2018 Infrared Technology 40 85
[25] 尹国应, 李爱珠 2020 光学与光电技术 18 18
Yin G Y, Li A Z 2020 Optics & Optoelectronic Technology 18 18
[26] 李佩赞, 王钦华 1994 仪器仪表学报 15 265
Google Scholar
Li P Z, Wang Q H 1994 Chin. J. Sci. Instrum. 15 265
Google Scholar
[27] 管国兴, 郑小明, 李佩赞 1988 红外研究 7A 201
Guan G X, Zheng X M, Li P Z 1988 Chin. J. Infrared Res. 7A 201
[28] 李佩赞, 王钦华 1996 物理 25 426
Li P Z, Wang Q H 1996 Physics 25 426
[29] 江海军, 陈力, 张淑仪 2014 无损检测 36 20
Jiang H J, Chen L, Zhang S Y 2014 Nondestructive Testing 36 20
[30] 江海军, 陈力, 苏清风, 邢建湘 2018 无损检测 40 15
Google Scholar
Jiang H J, Chen L, Su Q F, Xing J X 2018 Nondestructive Testing 40 15
Google Scholar
[31] 江海军, 陈力 2018 红外技术 40 946
Google Scholar
Jiang H J, Chen L 2018 Infrared Technology 40 946
Google Scholar
DownLoad:
Catalog
Metrics
- Abstract views: 4077
- PDF Downloads: 89
- Cited By: 0
