三明治结构柔性储能电介质材料研究进展

李雨凡; 薛文清; 李玉超; 战艳虎; 谢倩; 李艳凯; 查俊伟

doi:10.7498/aps.73.20230614

摘要

聚合物电介质材料因其高功率密度、耐击穿、安全柔韧、易加工和自愈性等特点, 被广泛应用于智能电网、新能源汽车、航空航天、国防科技等领域. 其中, 基于三明治结构设计获得具有更高储能密度和储能效率的柔性电介质材料成为近年来聚合物储能电介质领域的研究热点和常用策略. 本文从电介质的材料构成、结构设计以及制备方法等角度综述了基于三明治结构聚合物电介质薄膜在储能密度提升方面的研究进展, 阐述了三明治结构电介质材料性能调控的微观机制和协同增强机理, 并展望了其发展趋势和应用前景.

关键词:

柔性 /
三明治 /
储能 /
电介质 /
研究进展

Abstract

Polymer dielectric materials show wide applications in smart power grids, new energy vehicles, aerospace, and national defense technologies due to the ultra-high power density, large breakdown strength, flexibility, easy processing, and self-healing characteristics. With the rapid development of integration, miniaturization and lightweight production of electronic devices, it is required to develop such a storage and transportation dielectric system with larger energy storage density, higher charge and discharge efficiency, good thermostability and being environmentally friendly. However, the contradiction between dielectric constant and breakdown strength of dielectric materials is the key factor and bottleneck to obtain a high performance dielectric material. It is accepted that controlling charge distribution and inhibiting charge carrier injection are important to improve the energy storage characteristics of polymer dielectrics. In recent years, the materials with sandwiched or stacking structures have demonstrated outstanding advantages in inhibiting charge injection and promoting polarization, allowing polymer dielectrics to have increased permittivity and breakdown strength at the same time. Therefore, from the perspectives of material composition, structural design, and preparation methods, this study reviews the research progress of polymer dielectric films with sandwiched structure in improving the energy storage performance. The influence of dielectric polarization, charge distribution, charge injection, interfacial barrier and electrical dendrite growth on the energy storage performance and the synergistic enhancement mechanisms in such sandwich-structured dielectric materials are systematically summarized, showing good development and vast application prospects.In brief, introducing easy polarization, wide-gap and deep-trap nanofillers has greater designability and regulation in the dielectric and breakdown properties. In addition, using the hard layer as the outer layer can reduce charge injection more effectively, resulting in a high breakdown resistance performance that is easy to achieve. The sandwiched structure design also possesses advantages over other methods in maintaining good flexibility and dielectric stability of dielectric materials, thus having become a hot-topic research area in recent years. In the future, it is necessary to combine low conductivity and high thermal conductivity of dielectric polymers to realize high temperature energy storage and efficiency. Researches on recyclable, self-repairing sandwiched insulating films are good for the service life and safety of electronic components and will further expand the application scope of dielectric polymers. Finally, effective evaluation of dielectric with sandwiched structure and energy storage performances through simulation and theoretical modeling is very helpful in revealing the breakdown mechanism and thermal failure mechanism, and also in theoretically guiding the design of polymer dielectric materials.

Keywords:

作者及机构信息

1.
聊城大学材料科学与工程学院, 聊城　252059

2.
北京科技大学化学与生物工程学院, 北京　100083

通信作者: 李玉超, liyuchao@lcu.edu.cn ; 查俊伟, zhajw@ustb.edu.cn

基金项目: 国家自然科学基金(批准号: 52177020, 52277022)和大学生创新创业训练计划(批准号: CXCY2022184)资助的课题.

Authors and contacts

1.
Department of Materials Science and Engineering, Liaocheng University, Liaocheng 252059, China

2.
School of Chemistry and Biological Engineering, University of Science and Technology Beijing, Beijing 100083, China

Corresponding author: Li Yu-Chao, liyuchao@lcu.edu.cn ; Zha Jun-Wei, zhajw@ustb.edu.cn

Funds: Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 52177020, 52277022) and the College Student Innovation and Entrepreneurship Training Program, China (Grant No. CXCY2022184).

文章全文 : translate this paragraph

参考文献

[1]	Palneedi H, Peddigari M, Hwang G T, Jeong D Y, Ryu J 2018 Adv. Funct. Mater. 28 1803665 Google Scholar
[2]	Feng Q K, Zhong S L, Pei J Y, Zhao Y, Zhang D L, Liu DF, Zhang Y X, Dang Z M 2022 Chem. Rev. 122 3820 Google Scholar
[3]	成桑, 李雨抒, 梁家杰, 李琦 2020 高分子学报 51 469 Google Scholar Cheng S, Li Y S, Liang J J, Li Q 2020 Acta Polym. Sin. 51 469 Google Scholar
[4]	查俊伟, 查磊军, 郑明胜 2023 物理学报 72 018401 Google Scholar Zha J W, Zha L J, Zheng M S 2023 Acta Phys. Sin. 72 018401 Google Scholar
[5]	郑明胜, 查俊伟, 党智敏 2017 电工技术学报 32 37 Google Scholar Zheng M S, Zha J W, Dang Z M 2017 Trans. Chin. Electrotechn. Soc. 32 37 Google Scholar
[6]	Yang Z J, Yue D, Yao Y H, Li J L, Chi Q G, Chen Q G, Min D M, Feng Y 2022 Polymers 14 1160 Google Scholar
[7]	Li Z J, Treich G M, Tefferi M, Wu C, Nasreen S, Scheirey S K, Ramprasad R, Sotzingc G A, Cao Y 2019 J. Mater. Chem. A 7 15026 Google Scholar
[8]	Hu H L, Zhang F, Luo S B, Chang W K, Yue J L, Wang C H 2020 Nano Energy 74 104844 Google Scholar
[9]	Zhu Y F, Zhang Z B, Litt M H, Zhu L 2018 Macromolecules 51 6257 Google Scholar
[10]	Zha J W, Zheng M S, Fan B H, Dang Z M 2021 Nano Energy 89 106438 Google Scholar
[11]	Sessler G M 1997 IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul. 4 614 Google Scholar
[12]	Wang Z, Yang L, Yang Y Z, Li Y C, Zhan Y H, Li Y K 2023 J. Liaocheng Univ. 36 67 [王振, 杨柳, 杨永志, 李玉超, 战艳虎, 李艳凯 2023 聊城大学学报 36 67 Wang Z, Yang L, Yang Y Z, Li Y C, Zhan Y H, Li Y K 2023 J. Liaocheng Univ. 36 67 [王振, 杨柳, 杨永志, 李玉超, 战艳虎, 李艳凯 2023 聊城大学学报 36 67
[13]	Wei J J, Zhu L 2020 Prog. Polym. Sci. 106 101254 Google Scholar
[14]	Chen G J, Zhang J F, Shi X Y, Peng H L, Chen X 2020 IET Nanodielectrics 3 81 Google Scholar
[15]	Yang C, Hao S J, Dai S L, Zhang X Y 2017 Carbon 117 301 Google Scholar
[16]	Liu F H, Li Q, Li Z Y, Dong L J, Xiong C X, Wang Q 2018 Composites Part A 109 597 Google Scholar
[17]	沈忠慧, 江彦达, 李宝文, 张鑫 2020 物理学报 69 217706 Google Scholar Shen Z H, Jiang Y D, Li B W, Zhang X 2020 Acta Phys. Sin. 69 217706 Google Scholar
[18]	Li C S, Chen G J, Qiu X L, Lou Q W, Gao X L 2021 AIP Adv. 11 065227 Google Scholar
[19]	Yin L, Wang Q, Zhao H, Bai J B 2023 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 15 16079 Google Scholar
[20]	Wang L, Luo H, Zhou X F, Yuan X, Zhou K C, Zhang D 2019 Composites Part A 117 369-376 Google Scholar
[21]	Chen J, Wang Y F, Yuan Q B, Xu X W, Niu Y J, Wang Q, Wang H 2018 Nano Energy 54 288 Google Scholar
[22]	Guo R, Luo H, Yan M Y, Zhou X F, Zhou C K, Zhang D 2021 Nano Energy 79 105412 Google Scholar
[23]	Bai H R, Zhu K, Wang Z, Shen B, Zhai J W 2021 Adv. Funct. Mater. 31 2102646 Google Scholar
[24]	Wang R, Xie C Z, Luo S K, Xu H S, Gou B, Zhou J G, Yang H 2021 ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 4 6135 Google Scholar
[25]	Dong J F, Hu R C, Xu X W, Chen J, Niu Y J, Wang F, Hao J Y, Wu K, Wang Q, Wang H 2021 Adv. Funct. Mater. 31 2102644 Google Scholar
[26]	Wei W T, Huang C, Zhang L Y, Wang Y, Xu M Y, Deng Y 2020 Chem. Eng. J. 394 125052 Google Scholar
[27]	Sun Z Q, Shi B F, Zhang T R, Yang W J, Wang J P, Zhang L X, Xue D Z, Wang Z P, Kang F, Zhang X X 2022 ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 5 8211 Google Scholar
[28]	Feng M J, Zhang T D, Song C H, Zhang C H, Zhang Y, Feng Y, Chi Q G, Chen Q G, Lei Q Q 2020 Polymers (Basel) 12 1972 Google Scholar
[29]	Li X J, Yang Y, Wang Y P, Pang S T, Shi J J, Ma X C, Zhu K J 2021 RSC Adv. 11 15177 Google Scholar
[30]	Wang C, He G H, Chen S H, Luo H, Yang Y, Zhang D 2022 J. Mater. Chem. A 10 9103 Google Scholar
[31]	Ahmad A, Liu G H, Cao S M, Liu X P, Luo J P, Han L, Tong H, Xu J 2023 Macromol. Rapid Commun. 44 2200568.Google Scholar
[32]	Chen J, Wang Y F, Xu X W, Yuan Q B, Niu Y J, Wang Q, Wang H, 2019 J. Mater. Chem. A 7 3729 Google Scholar
[33]	Wang C, He G H, Chen S H, Zhai D 2021 J. Mater. Chem. A 9 8674 Google Scholar
[34]	Chen J, Wang Y F, Xu X W, Yuan Q B, Niu Y J, Wang Q, Wang H 2018 J. Mater. Chem. A 6 24367 Google Scholar
[35]	Feng K Q, Zhang Y X, Liu D F, Song Y H, Huang L, Dang Z M 2022 Mater. Today Energy 29 101132 Google Scholar
[36]	Zhang W C, Guan F, Jiang M, Li Y P, Zhu C C, Yue D, Li J L, Liu X X, Feng Y 2022 Composites Part A 159 107018 Google Scholar
[37]	Zhu K, Jiang P K, Huang X Y 2018 IET Nanodielectrics 1 127 Google Scholar
[38]	Zhang Y, Chi Q G, Liu L Z, Zhang C H, Chen C, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2017 APL Mater. 5 076109 Google Scholar
[39]	Wang Y F, Jin C, Yan Q B, Niu Y J, Bai Y Y, Wang H 2015 Adv. Mater. 27 6658 Google Scholar
[40]	Chen F J, Zhou Y J, Guo J M, Sun S, Zhao Y T, Yang Y J, Xu J H 2020 RSC Adv. 10 2295 Google Scholar
[41]	Meng G D, She J Y, Wang C L, Wang W K, Pan C, Cheng Y H 2022 Front. Chem. 10 910305 Google Scholar
[42]	Liang X W, Yu X C, Lü L L, Zhao T, Luo S B, Yu S H, Sun R, Wong C P, Zhu P L 2020 Nano Energy 68 104351 Google Scholar
[43]	Liu G, Zhang T D, Feng Y, Zhang Y Q, Zhang C H, Zhang Y, Wang X B, Chi Q G, Chen Q G, Lei Q Q 2020 Chem. Eng. J. 389 124443 Google Scholar
[44]	Cheng L, Liu K, Gao H Y, Fan Z M, Takesue N, Deng H M, Zhang H B, Hu Y M, Tan H, Yan Z L, Liu Y 2022 Chem. Eng. J. 435 135064 Google Scholar
[45]	Guo Y T, Wu S H, Liu S H, Xu J, Pawlikowska E, Szafran M, Rydosz A, Gao F 2022 Mater. Lett. 306 130910 Google Scholar
[46]	Chen J, Li Y, Wang Y F, Dong J F, Xu X W, Yuan Q B, Niu Y J, Wang Q, Wang H 2020 Compos. Sci. Technol. 186 107912 Google Scholar
[47]	迟庆国, 陈辰, 张月, 张昌海, 王暄, 雷清泉 2017 高电压技术 43 2204 Google Scholar Chi Q G, Chen C, Zhang Y, Zhang C H, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2017 High Volt. Eng. 43 2204 Google Scholar
[48]	Hu P H, Shen Y, Guan Y H, Zhang X H, Lin Y H, Zhang Q M, Nan C W 2014 Adv. Funct. Mater. 24 3172 Google Scholar
[49]	Marwat M A, Xie B, Zhu Y W, Fan P Y, Ma W G, Liu H M, Ashtar M, Xiao J Z, Salamon D, Samart C, Zhang H B 2019 Composites Part A 121 115 Google Scholar
[50]	Marwat M A, Yasar M, Ma W G, Fan P Y, Liu K, Lu D J, Tian Y, Samart C, Ye B H, Zhang H B 2020 ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 3 6591 Google Scholar
[51]	Yin L, Zhao H, Wang Y Z, Zhao S N, Ding X Y, Wang Q, Wei X P, Miao Z Y, Yang F, Yin X Q, Bai J B 2022 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 14 39311 Google Scholar
[52]	Qiu J Y, Weng L, Zhang X R, Su Y 2022 IET Nanodielectrics 5 85 Google Scholar
[53]	Zhang Y, Zhang T D, Liu L Z, Chi Q G, Zhang C H, Chen Q J, Cui Y, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2018 J. Phys.C122 1500 Google Scholar
[54]	Liu F H, Li Q, Cui J, Li Z Y, Yang G, Liu Y, Dong L J, Xiong C X, Wang H, Wang Q 2017 Adv. Funct. Mater. 271606292 Google Scholar
[55]	Wang H, Wang Y, Wang B Y, Li M Q, Li M T, Wang F, Li C L, Diao C L, Lou H, Zheng H W 2022 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 14 55130 Google Scholar
[56]	Wang Z Z, Feng Z P, Tang H S, Wang J H, Cai Z M, Bi K, Hao Y A 2022 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 14 42513 Google Scholar
[57]	Li W X, Yang T N, Liu C S, Huang Y H, Chen C X, Pan H, Xie G Z, Tai H L, Jinag Y D, Wu Y J, Kang Z, Chen L Q, Su Y J, Hong Z J 2022 Adv Sci. 9 2105550 Google Scholar
[58]	Shen Z H, Wang J J, Jiang J Y, Huang S R, Lin Y H, Nan C W, Chen L Q, Shen Y 2019 Nat. Commun. 10 1843 Google Scholar
[59]	Shen Y, Hua Y H, Chen W W, Wang J J, Guan Y H, Dua J W, Zhang X, Ma J, Lia M, Lin Y H, Chen L Q, Nan C W 2015 Nano Energy 18 176 Google Scholar
[60]	Zhang K Y, Ma Z Y, Fu Q, Deng H 2022 Mater. Today Energy 29 101093 Google Scholar
[61]	Xie H R, Wang L, Gao X, Lou H, Liu L H, Zhang D 2020 ACS Omega 5 32660 Google Scholar
[62]	Zhang Y J, Yang H B, Dang Z N, Zhan S L, Sun C, Hu G L, Lin Y, Yuan Q B 2020 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 12 22137 Google Scholar
[63]	Jiang J Y, Shen Z H, Qian J F, Dan Z K, Guo M F, Lin Y H, Nan C W, Chen L Q, Shen Y 2019 Energy Storage Mater. 18 213 Google Scholar
[64]	Jiang Y D, Zhang X, Shen Z H, Li X H, Yan J J, Li B W, Nan C W 2020 Adv. Funct. Mater. 30 1906112 Google Scholar
[65]	Wang Y F, Li Y, Wang L X, Yuan Q B, Chen J, Niu Y J, Xu X W, Wang Q, Wang H 2020 Energy Storage Mater. 24 626 Google Scholar
[66]	Zhang Y, Chi Q G, Liu L Z, Zhang T D, Zhang T D, Zhang C H, Chen Q G, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2018 ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 1 6320 Google Scholar
[67]	Sun L, Shi Z C, He B L, Wang H L, Liu S, Huang M H, Shi J, Dastan D, Wang H 2021 Adv. Funct. Mater. 31 2100280 Google Scholar
[68]	Cui Y, Zhang T D, Feng Y, Zhang C H, Chi Q G, Zhang Y Q, Chen Q G, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2019 Composites Part B 177 107429 Google Scholar
[69]	Lin B, Chen G D, He F A, Li Y, Yang Y, Shi B, Feng F R, Chen S Y, Lam K H 2023 Diamond Relat. Mater. 131 109556 Google Scholar
[70]	Hu J, Zhang S F, Tang B T 2021 Energy Storage Mater. 37 530 Google Scholar
[71]	Jiang J, Shen Z H, Qian J F, Dan Z K, Guo M F, He Y, Lin Y H, Nan C W, Chen L Q, Shen Y 2019 Nano Energy 62 220 Google Scholar
[72]	董久锋, 邓星磊, 牛玉娟, 潘子钊, 汪宏. 2020 物理学报 69 217701 Google Scholar Dong J F, Deng X L, Niu Y J, Pan Z Z, Wang H 2020 Acta Phys. Sin. 69 217701 Google Scholar
[73]	Hassan Y A, Hu H L 2020 Composites Part A 138 106064 Google Scholar
[74]	Chen J, Zhou Y, Huang X Y, Yu C Y, Han D L, Wang A, Zhu Y K, Shi K M, Kang Q, Li P L, Jiang P K, Qian X S, Bao H, Li S T, Wu G N, Zhu X Y, Wang Q 2023 Nature 615 62 Google Scholar
[75]	Wan B Q, Zheng M S, Yang X, Dong X D, Li Y C, Mai Y W, Chen G, Zha J W 2023 Energy Environ. Mater. 6 e12427 Google Scholar

施引文献

图 1 (a) 介质材料极化储能过程^[5]; (b) 介电材料的D-E曲图^[6]

Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of (a) polarization^[5] and (b) D-E loop of dielectric materials^[6].

下载: 全尺寸图片幻灯片

图 2 BN和TiO₂协同提升三明治结构电介质材料储能机理^[19]

Fig. 2. Synergistic enhancement of energy storage mechanism of sandwich structure composite by BN and TiO₂^[19].

下载: 全尺寸图片幻灯片

图 3 三明治结构　(a) 全有机P(VDF-HFP)-PMMA-P(VDF-HFP)薄膜^[21]; (b) 有机/无机PVDF-BT/PVDF-PVDF薄膜^[22]; (c) BN, Sr₂Nb₂O₇协同增强PMMA/PVDF电介质薄膜^[23]; (d) PI-Al₂O₃-PI薄膜示意图^[25]

Fig. 3. Diagram of sandwich structure: (a) All-organic composite film of P(VDF-HFP)-PMMA-P(VDF-HFP)^[21], (b) organic/inorganic composite film of PVDF-BT/PVDF-PVDF^[22], (c) BN, Sr₂Nb₂O₇ synergistically reinforced PMMA/PVDF dielectric film^[23] and (d) PI-Al₂O₃-PI composite film^[25].

下载: 全尺寸图片幻灯片

图 4 (a) 对称型A-B-A和B-A-B三明治结构电介质材料示意图; (b) 不同结构电介质材料的储能密度^[45]; (c) 相场模拟不同结构复合电介质材料的失效概率与场强关系^[59]

Fig. 4. (a) Schematics of symmetric A-B-A and B-A-B types of sandwich structure; (b) different energy storage density ^[45] and (c) failure probability versus electric field ^[59] of A-B-A and B-A-B types of structure.

下载: 全尺寸图片幻灯片

图 5 (a) 五层结构PVDF-SNBT/PVDF-PVDF复合薄膜结构示意图^[62]; (b) 对称梯度结构BZCT/PVDF多层膜材料示意图^[66]; (c) 非对称梯度结构PEI-PEI/P(VDF-HFP)-P(VDF-HFP)薄膜示意图^[67]

Fig. 5. Schematic of (a) a five-layer dielectric composite film^[62], (b) a symmetrically gradient dielectric film^[66] , and (c) an asymmetrically gradient PEI-PEI/P(VDF-HFP)-P(VDF-HFP) film^[67].

下载: 全尺寸图片幻灯片

图 6 (a) 流延工艺^[21]及其(b) PMMA/PVDF-BCZT/PVDF-PMMA/PVDF薄膜扫描电镜图 ^[68]; (c) 旋涂工艺及其(d) BT@HPC/PVDF-PVDF-BT@HPC/PVDF薄膜扫描电镜图^[42]

Fig. 6. Sandwich structure composite films prepared by (a) flow casting^[21] and (b) representative SEM image of PMMA/PVDF-BCZT/PVDF-PMMA/PVDF dielectric film ^[68], (c) spin coating process and (d) representative SEM image of BT@HPC/PVDF-PVDF-BT@HPC/PVDF film^[42].

下载: 全尺寸图片幻灯片

图 7 (a) 热压法制备FPE-P(VDF-HFP)-FPE三明治结构薄膜的制备过程和扫描电镜图^[36]; (b) 静电纺丝制备P(VDF-HFP)和BT/P(VDF-HFP)多层膜结构及其扫描电镜图^[71]

Fig. 7. (a) Hot-compression molding process of FPE-P(VDF-HFP)-FPE sandwich film and SEM image^[36]_; (b) electrostatic spinning preparation of P(VDF-HFP) and BT/P(VDF-HFP) multilayer film and its SEM image^[71].

下载: 全尺寸图片幻灯片

表 1 不同材料构成A-B-A型三明治电介质材料的介电性能

Table 1. Dielectric properties of A-B-A type sandwich dielectric materials

材料构成	A层(含量, 厚度)	B层(含量, 厚度)	A-B-A三明治(25 ℃, 1 kHz)
材料构成	A层(含量, 厚度)	B层(含量, 厚度)	$\varepsilon_{\mathrm{r}} $	tanδ	E/(MV·m^–1)	U/(J·cm^–3)	η/%	制备方法	U/U_基体	文献
全有机复合	PVDF (3 μm)	P(VDF-TrFE-CTFE) (3 μm)	12.06	0.35	599	20.86	60	溶液涂膜	1.3	[20]
	P(VDF-HFP) (6.5 μm)	PMMA (6 μm)	7	0.03	440	20.3	84	溶液浇筑	1.3	[21]
	PVDF (4 μm)	P(VDF-TrFE)-PVDF (70% PVDF, volume percent, 10 μm)	12	0.03	582	23.4	65.5	溶液浇筑	1.5	[26]
	P(VH-HFP) (3 μm)	P(VDF-HFP)-PMMA (25% PMMA, weight percent, 4 μm)	9	0.25	680	28	74	热压、拉伸	1.8	[27]
	P(VDF-TrFE-CFE) (4 μm)	PMMA (13 μm)	5	0.05	399.1	9.7	78	静电纺丝、热压	1.7	[28]
	P(VDF-TrFE-CFE) (2 μm)	PVDF (2 μm)	10.2	0.02	550.9	18.3	60	溶液涂覆	2.44	[29]
	PMMA-P(VDF-TrFE-CFE) (20% PMMA, weight percent, 4 μm)	DE-P(VDF-TrFE-CFE) (15% DE, weight percent, 4 μm)	7	0.05	790	20.1	66	溶液浇筑	2.5	[30]
	Parylene (1 μm)	PI (17 μm)	5.04	0.43	460	4.72	44.8	CVD	2.9	[31]
	DE-P(VDF-HFP) (30% DE, weight percent, 2.5 μm)	PMMA (14.5μm)	—	—	300	11.8	89	溶液浇筑	1.45	[32]
	PEI (4.5 μm)	P(VDF-TrFE-CFE) (3 μm)	~7	0.03	504	8	81	溶液浇筑	2.6	[33]
	P(VDF-TrFE-CFE) (3.4 μm)	PEI (6.7 μm)	~5	0.01	275	4	80	溶液浇筑	1.3	[33]
	PVDF (6.5 μm)	DE (4 μm)	10.4	0.03	438	20.92	72	溶液浇筑	1.3	[34]
	PET (2 μm)	P(VDF-HFP) (5 μm)	4.5	0.01	583.2	8.2	86.4	溶液浇筑	1.17	[35]
	Fluorene polyester (7 μm)	P(VDF-HFP) (4 μm)	4	0.014	564	8	86.7	溶液浇筑、热压	1.1	[36]
	PMMA (4 μm)	P(VDF-TrFE-CFE) (9 μm)	4.5	0.05	—	7.03	78	溶液浇筑	1.55	[37]
	PVDF (9 μm)	P(VDF-TrFE-CFE) (16 μm)	16	0.03	408	8.7	60	溶液浇筑、热压	2	[38]
有机/无机杂化	BN/PVDF (2%, weight percent, 4 μm)	TiO₂/PVDF (3%, weight percent, 4 μm)	11.42	0.03	369.9	10.17	56	溶液浇筑、热压	5	[19]
	PVDF (3 μm)	BT@SiO2@PDA/PVDF (3 μm)	12	0.023	634	15.3	64	溶液浇筑	3.85	[24]
	BT/PVDF (3%, weight percent, 4 μm)	PVDF (4 μm)	13.3	<0.025	505	15	60	溶液浇筑	1.6	[22]
	PVDF (4 μm)	BT/PVDF (3%, 4 μm)	12.9	<0.025	519.7	19.1	68.6	溶液浇筑	2.3	[22]
	BT/PVDF (20%, volume percent, 5 μm)	BT/PVDF (1%, volume percent, 10 μm)	17.5	0.05	470	18.8	—	溶液浇筑	4.5	[39]
	BT/P(VDF-HFP) (10%, weight percent, 5 μm)	BNNs (3 μm)	10.99	0.05	414.76	8.37	50	溶液浇筑	2.26	[40]
	h-BN (70 nm)	PVDF (12 μm)	~9.5	0.024	464.7	19.26	52.2	CVD、热压	2.7	[41]
	BT@HPC/PVDF (1%, weight percent, 5 μm)	PVDF (5 μm)	15	0.02	360	10.2	77	旋涂	5.1	[42]
	h-BN (2 μm)	PC (12 μm)	3.15	0.015	—	5.01	80.82	静电纺丝、热压	1.16	[43]
	P(VDF-CTFE)/PMMA (3 μm)	Ag@SrTiO₃/P(VDF-CTFE) (1.5%, weight percent, 5 μm)	7.2	0.041	635.4	24.6	86.3	溶液浇筑	6.15	[44]
	PVDF (8 μm)	BST/PVDF (40%, volume percent, 14μm)	~15	0.025	230.8	7.56	68.59	溶液浇筑、热压	1.89	[45]
	BST/PVDF (20%, volume percent, 8 μm)	PVDF (8 μm)	17.3	0.025	224.5	10.54	72.02	溶液浇筑、热压	2.63	[45]
	PMMA (6.6 μm)	P(VDF-HPF)/GO (2%, weight percent, 12 μm)	10	0.01	286	10.17	77	溶液浇筑	6.78	[46]
	BN/PVDF (8 μm)	BT/PVDF (8 μm)	12	0.02	370	6.2	55	溶液浇筑	1.55	[47]
	BT-np/PVDF (10%, volume percent, 3.5 μm)	BT-nf/PVDF (2%, volume percent, 5.5 μm)	10.5	0.015	453	9.72	—	逐层流延	2.43	[48]
	BT/PMMA (1%, weight percent, 5 μm)	BT/PMMA(9%, weight percent, 10 μm)	7.15	0.05	501.4	6.08	—	溶液浇筑	4.05	[49]
	P(VDF-HFP) (5 μm)	Ag@BN/PEI (5%, weight percent, 5 μm)	5.9	0.018	510	11	80	热压法	—	[50]
	PVDF (5 μm)	NBT@TO/PVDF (6%, weight percent, 10 μm)	12	0.025	304	15.42	66.12	逐层浇筑	3.8	[51]
	PVDF (10 μm)	PPy/TiO₂ (30%, weight percent, 20 μm)	16	0.02	99	2.68	66.7	静电纺丝、热压	1.1	[52]
	BZCT/PVDF (3 l%, volume percent, 10 μm)	Fe₃O₄@BNNS/PVDF (5%, volume percent, 10 μm)	16	0.03	350	8.9	—	溶液浇筑、热压	2.3	[53]
	BN/PVDF (10 %, weigh percent, 4 μm)	BST/PVDF (8%, weigh percent, 8 μm)	12	0.025	588	20.5	60	溶液浇筑	4	[54]
注: Na_0.5Bi_0.5TiO₃@TiO₂=NBT@TO, hollow porous carbon=HPC, BT-np (nf)= BT纳米颗粒(纳米片), Polypyrrole=PPy, 0.5 Ba(Zr_0.2Ti_0.8)O₃-0.5(Ba_0.7Ca_0.3)TiO₃=BZCT, polyacrylate elastomer=DE.

下载: 导出CSV

[1]	Palneedi H, Peddigari M, Hwang G T, Jeong D Y, Ryu J 2018 Adv. Funct. Mater. 28 1803665 Google Scholar
[2]	Feng Q K, Zhong S L, Pei J Y, Zhao Y, Zhang D L, Liu DF, Zhang Y X, Dang Z M 2022 Chem. Rev. 122 3820 Google Scholar
[3]	成桑, 李雨抒, 梁家杰, 李琦 2020 高分子学报 51 469 Google Scholar Cheng S, Li Y S, Liang J J, Li Q 2020 Acta Polym. Sin. 51 469 Google Scholar
[4]	查俊伟, 查磊军, 郑明胜 2023 物理学报 72 018401 Google Scholar Zha J W, Zha L J, Zheng M S 2023 Acta Phys. Sin. 72 018401 Google Scholar
[5]	郑明胜, 查俊伟, 党智敏 2017 电工技术学报 32 37 Google Scholar Zheng M S, Zha J W, Dang Z M 2017 Trans. Chin. Electrotechn. Soc. 32 37 Google Scholar
[6]	Yang Z J, Yue D, Yao Y H, Li J L, Chi Q G, Chen Q G, Min D M, Feng Y 2022 Polymers 14 1160 Google Scholar
[7]	Li Z J, Treich G M, Tefferi M, Wu C, Nasreen S, Scheirey S K, Ramprasad R, Sotzingc G A, Cao Y 2019 J. Mater. Chem. A 7 15026 Google Scholar
[8]	Hu H L, Zhang F, Luo S B, Chang W K, Yue J L, Wang C H 2020 Nano Energy 74 104844 Google Scholar
[9]	Zhu Y F, Zhang Z B, Litt M H, Zhu L 2018 Macromolecules 51 6257 Google Scholar
[10]	Zha J W, Zheng M S, Fan B H, Dang Z M 2021 Nano Energy 89 106438 Google Scholar
[11]	Sessler G M 1997 IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. Insul. 4 614 Google Scholar
[12]	Wang Z, Yang L, Yang Y Z, Li Y C, Zhan Y H, Li Y K 2023 J. Liaocheng Univ. 36 67 [王振, 杨柳, 杨永志, 李玉超, 战艳虎, 李艳凯 2023 聊城大学学报 36 67 Wang Z, Yang L, Yang Y Z, Li Y C, Zhan Y H, Li Y K 2023 J. Liaocheng Univ. 36 67 [王振, 杨柳, 杨永志, 李玉超, 战艳虎, 李艳凯 2023 聊城大学学报 36 67
[13]	Wei J J, Zhu L 2020 Prog. Polym. Sci. 106 101254 Google Scholar
[14]	Chen G J, Zhang J F, Shi X Y, Peng H L, Chen X 2020 IET Nanodielectrics 3 81 Google Scholar
[15]	Yang C, Hao S J, Dai S L, Zhang X Y 2017 Carbon 117 301 Google Scholar
[16]	Liu F H, Li Q, Li Z Y, Dong L J, Xiong C X, Wang Q 2018 Composites Part A 109 597 Google Scholar
[17]	沈忠慧, 江彦达, 李宝文, 张鑫 2020 物理学报 69 217706 Google Scholar Shen Z H, Jiang Y D, Li B W, Zhang X 2020 Acta Phys. Sin. 69 217706 Google Scholar
[18]	Li C S, Chen G J, Qiu X L, Lou Q W, Gao X L 2021 AIP Adv. 11 065227 Google Scholar
[19]	Yin L, Wang Q, Zhao H, Bai J B 2023 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 15 16079 Google Scholar
[20]	Wang L, Luo H, Zhou X F, Yuan X, Zhou K C, Zhang D 2019 Composites Part A 117 369-376 Google Scholar
[21]	Chen J, Wang Y F, Yuan Q B, Xu X W, Niu Y J, Wang Q, Wang H 2018 Nano Energy 54 288 Google Scholar
[22]	Guo R, Luo H, Yan M Y, Zhou X F, Zhou C K, Zhang D 2021 Nano Energy 79 105412 Google Scholar
[23]	Bai H R, Zhu K, Wang Z, Shen B, Zhai J W 2021 Adv. Funct. Mater. 31 2102646 Google Scholar
[24]	Wang R, Xie C Z, Luo S K, Xu H S, Gou B, Zhou J G, Yang H 2021 ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 4 6135 Google Scholar
[25]	Dong J F, Hu R C, Xu X W, Chen J, Niu Y J, Wang F, Hao J Y, Wu K, Wang Q, Wang H 2021 Adv. Funct. Mater. 31 2102644 Google Scholar
[26]	Wei W T, Huang C, Zhang L Y, Wang Y, Xu M Y, Deng Y 2020 Chem. Eng. J. 394 125052 Google Scholar
[27]	Sun Z Q, Shi B F, Zhang T R, Yang W J, Wang J P, Zhang L X, Xue D Z, Wang Z P, Kang F, Zhang X X 2022 ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 5 8211 Google Scholar
[28]	Feng M J, Zhang T D, Song C H, Zhang C H, Zhang Y, Feng Y, Chi Q G, Chen Q G, Lei Q Q 2020 Polymers (Basel) 12 1972 Google Scholar
[29]	Li X J, Yang Y, Wang Y P, Pang S T, Shi J J, Ma X C, Zhu K J 2021 RSC Adv. 11 15177 Google Scholar
[30]	Wang C, He G H, Chen S H, Luo H, Yang Y, Zhang D 2022 J. Mater. Chem. A 10 9103 Google Scholar
[31]	Ahmad A, Liu G H, Cao S M, Liu X P, Luo J P, Han L, Tong H, Xu J 2023 Macromol. Rapid Commun. 44 2200568.Google Scholar
[32]	Chen J, Wang Y F, Xu X W, Yuan Q B, Niu Y J, Wang Q, Wang H, 2019 J. Mater. Chem. A 7 3729 Google Scholar
[33]	Wang C, He G H, Chen S H, Zhai D 2021 J. Mater. Chem. A 9 8674 Google Scholar
[34]	Chen J, Wang Y F, Xu X W, Yuan Q B, Niu Y J, Wang Q, Wang H 2018 J. Mater. Chem. A 6 24367 Google Scholar
[35]	Feng K Q, Zhang Y X, Liu D F, Song Y H, Huang L, Dang Z M 2022 Mater. Today Energy 29 101132 Google Scholar
[36]	Zhang W C, Guan F, Jiang M, Li Y P, Zhu C C, Yue D, Li J L, Liu X X, Feng Y 2022 Composites Part A 159 107018 Google Scholar
[37]	Zhu K, Jiang P K, Huang X Y 2018 IET Nanodielectrics 1 127 Google Scholar
[38]	Zhang Y, Chi Q G, Liu L Z, Zhang C H, Chen C, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2017 APL Mater. 5 076109 Google Scholar
[39]	Wang Y F, Jin C, Yan Q B, Niu Y J, Bai Y Y, Wang H 2015 Adv. Mater. 27 6658 Google Scholar
[40]	Chen F J, Zhou Y J, Guo J M, Sun S, Zhao Y T, Yang Y J, Xu J H 2020 RSC Adv. 10 2295 Google Scholar
[41]	Meng G D, She J Y, Wang C L, Wang W K, Pan C, Cheng Y H 2022 Front. Chem. 10 910305 Google Scholar
[42]	Liang X W, Yu X C, Lü L L, Zhao T, Luo S B, Yu S H, Sun R, Wong C P, Zhu P L 2020 Nano Energy 68 104351 Google Scholar
[43]	Liu G, Zhang T D, Feng Y, Zhang Y Q, Zhang C H, Zhang Y, Wang X B, Chi Q G, Chen Q G, Lei Q Q 2020 Chem. Eng. J. 389 124443 Google Scholar
[44]	Cheng L, Liu K, Gao H Y, Fan Z M, Takesue N, Deng H M, Zhang H B, Hu Y M, Tan H, Yan Z L, Liu Y 2022 Chem. Eng. J. 435 135064 Google Scholar
[45]	Guo Y T, Wu S H, Liu S H, Xu J, Pawlikowska E, Szafran M, Rydosz A, Gao F 2022 Mater. Lett. 306 130910 Google Scholar
[46]	Chen J, Li Y, Wang Y F, Dong J F, Xu X W, Yuan Q B, Niu Y J, Wang Q, Wang H 2020 Compos. Sci. Technol. 186 107912 Google Scholar
[47]	迟庆国, 陈辰, 张月, 张昌海, 王暄, 雷清泉 2017 高电压技术 43 2204 Google Scholar Chi Q G, Chen C, Zhang Y, Zhang C H, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2017 High Volt. Eng. 43 2204 Google Scholar
[48]	Hu P H, Shen Y, Guan Y H, Zhang X H, Lin Y H, Zhang Q M, Nan C W 2014 Adv. Funct. Mater. 24 3172 Google Scholar
[49]	Marwat M A, Xie B, Zhu Y W, Fan P Y, Ma W G, Liu H M, Ashtar M, Xiao J Z, Salamon D, Samart C, Zhang H B 2019 Composites Part A 121 115 Google Scholar
[50]	Marwat M A, Yasar M, Ma W G, Fan P Y, Liu K, Lu D J, Tian Y, Samart C, Ye B H, Zhang H B 2020 ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 3 6591 Google Scholar
[51]	Yin L, Zhao H, Wang Y Z, Zhao S N, Ding X Y, Wang Q, Wei X P, Miao Z Y, Yang F, Yin X Q, Bai J B 2022 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 14 39311 Google Scholar
[52]	Qiu J Y, Weng L, Zhang X R, Su Y 2022 IET Nanodielectrics 5 85 Google Scholar
[53]	Zhang Y, Zhang T D, Liu L Z, Chi Q G, Zhang C H, Chen Q J, Cui Y, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2018 J. Phys.C122 1500 Google Scholar
[54]	Liu F H, Li Q, Cui J, Li Z Y, Yang G, Liu Y, Dong L J, Xiong C X, Wang H, Wang Q 2017 Adv. Funct. Mater. 271606292 Google Scholar
[55]	Wang H, Wang Y, Wang B Y, Li M Q, Li M T, Wang F, Li C L, Diao C L, Lou H, Zheng H W 2022 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 14 55130 Google Scholar
[56]	Wang Z Z, Feng Z P, Tang H S, Wang J H, Cai Z M, Bi K, Hao Y A 2022 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 14 42513 Google Scholar
[57]	Li W X, Yang T N, Liu C S, Huang Y H, Chen C X, Pan H, Xie G Z, Tai H L, Jinag Y D, Wu Y J, Kang Z, Chen L Q, Su Y J, Hong Z J 2022 Adv Sci. 9 2105550 Google Scholar
[58]	Shen Z H, Wang J J, Jiang J Y, Huang S R, Lin Y H, Nan C W, Chen L Q, Shen Y 2019 Nat. Commun. 10 1843 Google Scholar
[59]	Shen Y, Hua Y H, Chen W W, Wang J J, Guan Y H, Dua J W, Zhang X, Ma J, Lia M, Lin Y H, Chen L Q, Nan C W 2015 Nano Energy 18 176 Google Scholar
[60]	Zhang K Y, Ma Z Y, Fu Q, Deng H 2022 Mater. Today Energy 29 101093 Google Scholar
[61]	Xie H R, Wang L, Gao X, Lou H, Liu L H, Zhang D 2020 ACS Omega 5 32660 Google Scholar
[62]	Zhang Y J, Yang H B, Dang Z N, Zhan S L, Sun C, Hu G L, Lin Y, Yuan Q B 2020 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 12 22137 Google Scholar
[63]	Jiang J Y, Shen Z H, Qian J F, Dan Z K, Guo M F, Lin Y H, Nan C W, Chen L Q, Shen Y 2019 Energy Storage Mater. 18 213 Google Scholar
[64]	Jiang Y D, Zhang X, Shen Z H, Li X H, Yan J J, Li B W, Nan C W 2020 Adv. Funct. Mater. 30 1906112 Google Scholar
[65]	Wang Y F, Li Y, Wang L X, Yuan Q B, Chen J, Niu Y J, Xu X W, Wang Q, Wang H 2020 Energy Storage Mater. 24 626 Google Scholar
[66]	Zhang Y, Chi Q G, Liu L Z, Zhang T D, Zhang T D, Zhang C H, Chen Q G, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2018 ACS Appl. Energy Mater. 1 6320 Google Scholar
[67]	Sun L, Shi Z C, He B L, Wang H L, Liu S, Huang M H, Shi J, Dastan D, Wang H 2021 Adv. Funct. Mater. 31 2100280 Google Scholar
[68]	Cui Y, Zhang T D, Feng Y, Zhang C H, Chi Q G, Zhang Y Q, Chen Q G, Wang X, Lei Q Q 2019 Composites Part B 177 107429 Google Scholar
[69]	Lin B, Chen G D, He F A, Li Y, Yang Y, Shi B, Feng F R, Chen S Y, Lam K H 2023 Diamond Relat. Mater. 131 109556 Google Scholar
[70]	Hu J, Zhang S F, Tang B T 2021 Energy Storage Mater. 37 530 Google Scholar
[71]	Jiang J, Shen Z H, Qian J F, Dan Z K, Guo M F, He Y, Lin Y H, Nan C W, Chen L Q, Shen Y 2019 Nano Energy 62 220 Google Scholar
[72]	董久锋, 邓星磊, 牛玉娟, 潘子钊, 汪宏. 2020 物理学报 69 217701 Google Scholar Dong J F, Deng X L, Niu Y J, Pan Z Z, Wang H 2020 Acta Phys. Sin. 69 217701 Google Scholar
[73]	Hassan Y A, Hu H L 2020 Composites Part A 138 106064 Google Scholar
[74]	Chen J, Zhou Y, Huang X Y, Yu C Y, Han D L, Wang A, Zhu Y K, Shi K M, Kang Q, Li P L, Jiang P K, Qian X S, Bao H, Li S T, Wu G N, Zhu X Y, Wang Q 2023 Nature 615 62 Google Scholar
[75]	Wan B Q, Zheng M S, Yang X, Dong X D, Li Y C, Mai Y W, Chen G, Zha J W 2023 Energy Environ. Mater. 6 e12427 Google Scholar

[1]	王辉, 郑德旭, 姜箫, 曹越先, 杜敏永, 王开, 刘生忠, 张春福. 基于协同钝化策略制备高性能柔性钙钛矿太阳能电池. 物理学报, 2024, 73(7): 078401. doi: 10.7498/aps.73.20231846
[2]	郑明, 杨健, 张怡笑, 关朋飞, 程奥, 范贺良. Sm³⁺掺杂0.94Bi_0.5Na_0.5TiO₃-0.06BaTiO₃无机多功能陶瓷的储能行为和光致发光性质. 物理学报, 2023, 72(17): 177801. doi: 10.7498/aps.72.20230685
[3]	殷敬伟, 马丁一, 张宇翔, 生雪莉. 极地海冰声波导建模综述. 物理学报, 2022, 71(8): 084301. doi: 10.7498/aps.71.20211950
[4]	陈乐迪, 范仁浩, 刘雨, 唐贡惠, 马中丽, 彭茹雯, 王牧. 基于柔性超构材料宽带调控太赫兹波的偏振态. 物理学报, 2022, 71(18): 187802. doi: 10.7498/aps.71.20220801
[5]	李燕, 贺红, 党威武, 陈雪莲, 孙璨, 郑嘉璐. 钙钛矿太阳电池中各功能层的光辐照稳定性研究进展. 物理学报, 2021, 70(9): 098402. doi: 10.7498/aps.70.20201762
[6]	玄鑫淼, 王加恒, 毛彦琦, 叶利娟, 张红, 李泓霖, 熊元强, 范嗣强, 孔春阳, 李万俊. 基于云母衬底生长的非晶Ga₂O₃柔性透明日盲紫外光探测器研究. 物理学报, 2021, 70(23): 238502. doi: 10.7498/aps.70.20211039
[7]	董久锋, 邓星磊, 牛玉娟, 潘子钊, 汪宏. 面向高温介电储能应用的聚合物基电介质材料研究进展. 物理学报, 2020, 69(21): 217701. doi: 10.7498/aps.69.20201006
[8]	蓝顺, 潘豪, 林元华. 柔性无机铁电薄膜的制备及其应用. 物理学报, 2020, 69(21): 217708. doi: 10.7498/aps.69.20201365
[9]	谈溥川, 赵超超, 樊瑜波, 李舟. 自驱动柔性生物医学传感器的研究进展. 物理学报, 2020, 69(17): 178704. doi: 10.7498/aps.69.20201012
[10]	周晓锋, 方浩宇, 唐春梅. 三明治结构graphene-2Li-graphene的储氢性能. 物理学报, 2019, 68(5): 053601. doi: 10.7498/aps.68.20181497
[11]	游家学, 王锦程, 王理林, 王志军, 李俊杰, 林鑫. 悬浮液凝固研究进展. 物理学报, 2019, 68(1): 018101. doi: 10.7498/aps.68.20181645
[12]	贾宁, 王善朋, 陶绪堂. 中远红外非线性光学晶体研究进展. 物理学报, 2018, 67(24): 244203. doi: 10.7498/aps.67.20181591
[13]	熊开欣, 席昆, 鲍磊, 张忠良, 谭志杰. 脱氧核糖核酸柔性的分子动力学模拟:Amber bsc1和bsc0力场的对比研究. 物理学报, 2018, 67(10): 108701. doi: 10.7498/aps.67.20180326
[14]	王承伟, 赵全忠, 钱静, 黄媛媛, 王关德, 李阳博, 柏锋, 范文中, 李虹瑾. 黑体辐射法测量电介质内部被超短激光脉冲加工后的温度. 物理学报, 2016, 65(12): 125201. doi: 10.7498/aps.65.125201
[15]	刘海文, 朱爽爽, 文品, 覃凤, 任宝平, 肖湘, 侯新宇. 基于发卡式开口谐振环的柔性双频带超材料. 物理学报, 2015, 64(3): 038101. doi: 10.7498/aps.64.038101
[16]	柴玉华, 郭玉秀, 卞伟, 李雯, 杨涛, 仪明东, 范曲立, 解令海, 黄维. 柔性有机非易失性场效应晶体管存储器的研究进展. 物理学报, 2014, 63(2): 027302. doi: 10.7498/aps.63.027302
[17]	董京, 柴玉华, 赵跃智, 石巍巍, 郭玉秀, 仪明东, 解令海, 黄维. 柔性有机场效应晶体管研究进展. 物理学报, 2013, 62(4): 047301. doi: 10.7498/aps.62.047301
[18]	张宪刚, 宗亚平, 吴艳. 相场再结晶储能释放模型与显微组织演变的模拟研究. 物理学报, 2012, 61(8): 088104. doi: 10.7498/aps.61.088104
[19]	丁佩, 周强, 胡伟琴, 蔡根旺, 梁二军. 利用电介质柱共振器实现电磁响应模式可转变的电磁超介质. 物理学报, 2011, 60(5): 054102. doi: 10.7498/aps.60.054102
[20]	韩永, 王体健, 饶瑞中, 王英俭. 大气气溶胶物理光学特性研究进展. 物理学报, 2008, 57(11): 7396-7407. doi: 10.7498/aps.57.7396

计量

文章访问数: 1232
PDF下载量: 68
被引次数: 0

姓名
邮箱
手机号码
标题
留言内容
验证码

搜索

留言板

三明治结构柔性储能电介质材料研究进展